Table 1.
Methods* | Principle | Materials | Applications | Advantages | Disadvantages | Manufacturers |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Material extrusion (Fused deposition modeling) | Nozzle prints melted filament onto a build platform followed by solidification | Acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS), poly lactic acid (PLA), polycarbonate (PC) polystyrene (PS), polyamide, polyetherimide (PEI) etc. | Immunosensor, Lactate sensor[56,91] | A wide range of materials can be used, faster compared to SLA, resolution ≈ 350 μm[92] | Requires support and parts can have lower strength compared to solid polymers.[93] | Makerbot, Ultimaker Prussa |
Material extrusion (Direct ink writing) | Liquid ink is extruded from a nozzle | Ceramic slurry, metal inks, graphene, carbon etc. | Metal electrodes,[71] microvascular networks[69] | Compatible with a variety of materials, including biological inks, can use multiple solidification methods[94] | To achieve small feature, ink formulation or specific process modifications are required[95] | Envision TEC 3D-Bioplotter, RepRap Prusa i3 printer |
Vat photopolymerization (Stereolithography) | UV light polymerization | Photoresins, ABS, PC, polyethylene, polypropylene, nanocomposite[96] | Cellular Sensor,[97] DNA sensor,[98] Bone tissue scaffold and biomedical implants.[99] | Simple and scalable process. Ability to pattern multiple resins in same layer with strong interlayer adhesion[100] | Lower mechanical strength compared to bulk polymers, difficulty in removing uncured resins, and can print only straight layers[101] | FabPro, Form2 |
Vat photopolymerization (Digital light processing) | Digital projector is used to cure photoresins | Photoesins, metal powders, polymers, ceramics | Glucose sensor,[102,103] motion sensor[103] | Faster than SLA, uncured photopolymer can be reused. | Difficulty in printing large structures,[104] and difficulty in controlling precise structural shape[105] | 3D PrinterPro, Fast Radius |
Vat photopolymerization (Two-photon polymerization) | Two photon absorption and polymerization | Polymers, negative or positive photoresists[106] | Tissue scaffolds,[107] lab-on-CMOS sensor[108] | Sub-100 nm resolution[109] | Requires sophisticated optical circuitry and positioning stage.[51] | TOPTICA Photonics AG, Aerotech |
Powder bed fusion (Selective laser sintering) | Laser source used to sinter powder particles | Metal powders, Nylon, Polyamide powders | Biomaterials,[110] pH sensors[75] | Fabrication of large parts,[111] resolution ≈100 μm | Requires more time compared to SLA and FDM, limited accuracy of features below a millimeter, requires post-printing processes, and challenging to control porosity.[112] | Fuse 1, Sintratec |
Material Jetting (Inkjet printing) | Extrusion of ink and powder liquid binding | Photo-resins, hydrogels, carbon nanotubes[113] | Bionic ear,[114] Bio-membrane[115] | Drop-on-demand, allows high-throughput cell patterning[116] and reactive ink can be printed without agglomeration[117] | Serial process, constrained by viscosity of solvents[118] | Hsausa, Inkcups, NanoDimension |
Material Jetting (Aerosol Jet Printing) | Aerosolized droplets delivered by a carrier gas to deposition nozzle and focused by a sheath gas | Metal nanoparticles, polymers, carbon nanotubes,[119] graphene, MXene | Glucose sensor,[87] Protein microarray[120] | Printing in 3D without support,[52] adoptable to a wide viscosity range,[121] and high resolution of 10μm | Particle size limited to < 500 nm, over-spray[122] | Optomec, Integrated Deposition Solutions (IDS) Inc. |
Categorization of 3D printing methods according to ASTM Standard F2792–12a[24]