Table 2.
Mean differences and RRs for sexual violence predicting mental health outcomes from a range of modelling approaches
Psychological distress in the past 30 days*, mean difference (95% CI) |
High psychological distress in the past 30 days, RR (95% CI) |
Self-harm in the past 12 months, RR (95% CI) |
Attempted suicide ever, RR (95% CI) |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Girls | Boys | Girls | Boys | Girls | Boys | Girls | Boys | |
Multivariable regressions | ||||||||
Unadjusted | 3·16 (2·52–3·81) | 3·75 (3·04–4·46) | 2·18 (1·79–2·66) | 2·41 (1·62–3·59) | 2·32 (1·99–2·71) | 3·09 (2·38–4·03) | 2·67 (2·01–3·54) | 4·17 (2·54–6·84) |
Adjustment 1 | 2·14 (1·47–2·81) | 2·11 (2·18–4·05) | 1·67 (1·36–2·05) | 1·87 (1·23–2·84) | 1·90 (1·60–2·25) | 2·62 (1·90–3·62) | 1·84 (1·32–2·56) | 3·00 (1·84–4·88) |
Adjustment 2 | 2·02 (1·37–2·67) | 2·59 (1·61–3·56) | 1·62 (1·32–1·98) | 1·58 (1·02–2·45) | 1·79 (1·52–2·09) | 2·23 (1·63–2·74) | 1·72 (1·22–2·41) | 2·80 (1·66–4·72) |
Adjustment 3 | 2·10 (1·45–2·75) | 2·57 (1·60–3·54) | 1·65 (1·35–2·02) | 1·57 (1·01–2·44) | 1·81 (1·54–2·12) | 2·22 (1·72–2·88) | 1·74 (1·24–2·43) | 2·60 (1·53–4·41) |
Adjustment 4 | 2·07 (1·44–2·71) | 2·64 (1·69–3·59) | 1·64 (1·35–1·99) | 1·64 (1·08–2·50) | 1·80 (1·54–2·11) | 2·24 (1·73–2·88) | 1·75 (1·26–2·44) | 2·60 (1·55–4·36) |
Fully adjusted model | 2·09 (1·51–2·68) | 2·56 (1·59–3·53) | 1·65 (1·37–2·00) | 1·55 (1·00–2·40) | 1·79 (1·52–2·10) | 2·16 (1·63–2·84) | 1·75 (1·26–2·41) | 2·73 (1·59–4·67) |
Matched samples | ||||||||
PSM (all matching variables) | 1·35 (0·88–1·81) | 2·73 (1·84–3·63) | 1·30 (1·14–1·49) | 1·97 (1·31–2·93) | 1·42 (1·28–1·58) | 1·92 (1·47–2·52) | 1·37 (1·11–1·70) | 2·28 (1·33–3·93) |
PSM (all variables minus sexual identity, pubertal status, parental education, and sexual violence before age 14 years) | 1·66 (1·19–2·14) | 3·29 (2·41–4·16) | 1·35 (1·18–1·54) | 2·68 (1·70–4·23) | 1·58 (1·41–1·77) | 2·18 (1·64–2·92) | 1·44 (1·16–1·79) | 4·28 (2·12–8·65) |
PSM (all variables minus high psychological distress, self-harm at age 14 years, and sexual violence before age 14 years) | 2·37 (1·92–2·83) | 3·53 (2·67–4·38) | 1·72 (1·48–2·00) | 3·11 (1·91–5·04) | 1·82 (1·62–2·06) | 2·24 (1·67–3·00) | 2·17 (1·69–2·80) | 4·83 (3·04–18·97) |
Matched sample with multivariable confounder adjustment | ||||||||
Adjusted regression analysis | 1·35 (0·92–1·79) | 2·54 (1·68–3·40) | 1·31 (1·16–1·49) | 1·87 (1·26–2·80) | 1·41 (1·27–1·57) | 1·83 (1·40–2·40) | 1·37 (1·11–1·68) | 2·36 (1·37–4·08) |
Multivariable adjusted regression by sexual violence type | ||||||||
Unwelcome sexual approach | 2·03 (1·44–2·63) | 2·61 (1·61–3·60) | 1·49 (1·34–1·65) | 1·88 (1·44–2·45) | 1·56 (1·44–1·70) | 1·99 (1·67–2·37) | 1·44 (1·21–1·71) | 2·54 (1·72–3·76) |
Sexual assault | 2·32 (1·49–3·15) | 3·82 (1·82–5·81) | 1·46 (1·27–1·68) | 1·87 (1·11–3·13) | 1·57 (1·41–1·75) | 2·09 (1·56–2·80) | 1·72 (1·40–2·11) | 2·63 (1·38–5·01) |
Unwelcome sexual approach only† | 1·51 (1·16–1·86) | 2·05 (1·49–2·60) | 1·45 (1·29–1·64) | 1·80 (1·36–2·38) | 1·49 (1·35–1·65) | 1·87 (1·54–2·26) | 1·27 (1·03–1·57) | 2·33 (1·55–3·53) |
The models had sequentially increasing amounts of adjustment. Adjustment 1 was for previous mental ill health (depressive symptoms and self-harm up to 14 years of age). Adjustment 2 added sociodemographic or economic characteristics (ethnicity, parental education, family income, sexual identity, single parent household, and number of siblings). Adjustment 3 added puberty-related characteristics (pubertal status, age of menarche [only girls], early sexual activity, and experience of sexual violence up to 14 years of age). Adjustment 4 added interpersonal characteristics (relationship status, peer relationships, and bullying). The fully adjusted model added health-related characteristics (BMI, risky behaviours, missing school without parents’ permission, disability, and life satisfaction). PSM=propensity score matching. RR=risk ratio.
This is a continuous measure.
Individuals who reported unwelcome sexual approach and no sexual assault.