Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 19;24(10):e37236. doi: 10.2196/37236

Table 1.

Identified challenges related to international data transfers, solutions currently explored, remaining challenges, and proposed solutions to these challenges.

Challenges Explored solutions Remaining challenges Suggested solutions
Lack of adequacy decision by the European Commission Creation of clear rules for the adequacy assessment procedure Blanket adequacy decisions easily disregard sectoral differences in applicable data protection rules Adopt specific health research sector adequacy assessments to take into account specific trade-offs among rights, appropriate technical measures, and long-standing compliance efforts within the sector, including administrative measures
Data anonymization and privacy-preserving data security measures are promoted as the only solutions to data protection concerns Nonapplication of data protection rules and instead use substitute measures to meet the adequacy standard Loss of information content of data for scientific research, anonymity of data is context dependent, and substitute measures for protection can be circumvented Emphasize the contextual anonymity of data, for example, when the context is not changed during data processing (eg, by allowing data to be visited)
Missing codes of conduct and certification mechanisms Bottom-up sector-specific concretization of data protection rules and appropriate supplementary security measures Current solutions that are not relevant to the context of genomic research or are not relevant for international data transfers [32]; fundamental rights issues raised Link the development of codes of conduct with the sectoral adequacy assessment and the development of certification mechanisms with supplementary technical measures for international data transfers