NCT01005888.
| Study characteristics | ||
| Methods |
Design: randomised, double‐blind, placebo‐controlled, cross‐over trial Exclusions postrandomisation: after completion of treatment, 3 participants (1 in C1‐INH group and 2 in placebo group) were judged by an independent, blinded expert to have had episodes that were not true attacks of HAE. Participants were then excluded from efficacy analysis Losses to follow‐up: during first period, 1 participants from each group withdrew, leaving 22 participants (11 in each group) who completed first period and then crossed over to other treatment for second period Duration of study: 2 × 12 weeks Unit of randomisation: participant |
|
| Participants |
Country: US Setting: outpatient Number: acute attack treatment trial: 68 participants (35 in C1‐INH group and 33 in placebo group); prophylaxis trial (11 in placebo with cross‐over to C1‐INH group and 11 in C1‐INH with cross‐over to placebo) Age (mean): 36.5 (SD 15.9) years Sex: 15 male (22.1%); 53 female (77.9%) Inclusion criteria: aged ≥ 6 years with confirmed diagnosis of HAE, including a low C4, normal C1q and a low antigenic or functional C1‐INH level or a mutation in the C1‐INH gene known to cause HAE. Exclusion criteria: low C1q level, history of a B‐cell cancer, presence of anti‐C1 inhibitor antibody, history of allergic reaction to C1‐INH or other blood or plasma products, pregnancy, and narcotic addiction. |
|
| Interventions | C1‐INH‐nf 1000 IU twice‐weekly Placebo (saline) twice‐weekly Treatment duration: 12 weeks then crossing over to other treatment |
|
| Outcomes | Rate of HAE attacks, attack severity, attack duration, use of rescue medication, functional C1 inhibitor, AEs | |
| Funding | Lev Pharmaceuticals (now owned by ViroPharma Biologics) | |
| Declarations of interest | Quote: "Dr. Zuraw reports receiving consulting fees from Lev Pharmaceuticals, CSL Behring, Jerini (now Shire), and Dyax; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Shire, and Dyax; fees for serving on the speakers bureau of the Robert Michael Educational Institute; grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Pharming, and Shire; and fees for providing expert testimony for Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Busse, receiving consulting fees and reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals; grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals and Shire Pharmaceuticals; fees for reviewing a patient file from Eichorn and Eichorn; payment for manuscript preparation from Innovative Strategic Communications; and fees for serving on the speakers bureaus of ViroPharma and the Robert Michael Educational Institute; Dr. White, receiving consulting fees from Lev Pharmaceuticals and Dyax; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Dyax; honoraria from Dyax; grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Dyax, Shire, ViroPharma, and Pharming; and fees for serving on the speakers bureau of ViroPharma; Dr. Jacobs, receiving consulting fees from ViroPharma; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals and ViroPharma; honoraria from ViroPharma; grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; and fees for serving on the speakers bureaus of ViroPharma and Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Lumry, receiving consulting fees and honoraria from ViroPharma; consulting fees from Dyax and Shire; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from ViroPharma, Dyax, and Shire; grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Dyax, and Shire; and payment for development of educational presentations from Dyax; Dr. Baker, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Shire, Dyax, and Pharming; Dr. Craig, receiving consulting fees from ViroPharma, Dyax, and CSL Behring; fees for participation in review activities and reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from ViroPharma; honoraria from ViroPharma, Dyax, and CSL Behring; grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, ViroPharma, Dyax, CSL Behring, Pharming, and Shire; and payment for development of educational presentations from Dyax, CSL Behring, and ViroPharma; Dr. Grant, receiving reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals and Dyax and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Dyax, and Shire; Dr. Hurewitz, receiving consulting fees from Shire; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from ViroPharma, Shire, Dyax, and CSL Behring; honoraria from Shire; and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, ViroPharma, Shire, Dyax, and CSL Behring; Dr. Bielory, receiving reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals and STARx Clinical Research Center; Dr. Cartwright, receiving grant support and consulting fees or honoraria from Lev Pharmaceuticals and ViroPharma; Dr. Koleilat, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Ryan, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Schaefer, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals and reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from ViroPharma; Dr. Manning, receiving reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals and ViroPharma; honoraria from ViroPharma; and payment for development of educational presentations from ViroPharma; Dr. Patel, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Bernstein, receiving consulting fees from Dynova, Lantheus, and Flint Hills Resources; honoraria from AstraZeneca, Alcon Labs, Dyax, ViroPharma, and CSL Behring; fees for providing expert testimony on environmental and drug reaction cases; and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals, Dyax, ViroPharma, CSL Behring, Shire, Pharming, Dynova, and Flint Hills Resources; and being listed as a patent holder on a patent held by the University of Cincinnati for a biosensor to detect airborne chemicals from Biosensors; Dr. Friedman, receiving reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from ViroPharma and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Wilkinson, receiving fees for study visits from Lev Pharmaceuticals and grant support from Dyax; Dr. Tanner, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Gunther, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Levy, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals and ViroPharma; consulting fees from CSL Behring, Alcon Labs, Dyax, Jerini, and Sepracor; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from CSL Behring and Dyax; and payment for manuscript preparation from Cadent Communications; Dr. McClellan, receiving a grant from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Redhead, receiving a grant from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Guss, receiving grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Heyman, receiving consulting fees from Lev Pharmaceuticals; Dr. Blumenstein, receiving consulting fees and reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals and ViroPharma; Dr. Kalfus, receiving consulting fees and reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from Lev Pharmaceuticals and ViroPharma; payment for development of educational presentations from ViroPharma; and stocks and stock options from Lev Pharmaceuticals; and being previously employed as vice president of medical affairs at Lev Pharmaceuticals; and Dr. Frank, receiving consulting fees from ViroPharma, CSL Behring, Shire, Dyax, and Pharming; fees for providing expert testimony for Lev Pharmaceuticals, Jerini, and CSL Behring; reimbursements for travel or accommodation expenses from ViroPharma; and grant support from Lev Pharmaceuticals and CSL Behring. No other potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported." | |
| Notes | Funded by Lev Pharmaceuticals but study performed externally. | |
| Risk of bias | ||
| Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
| Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Method of randomisation not stated. |
| Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Concealment of allocation not stated. |
| Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) | Low risk | Participants and personnel were blinded. |
| Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) | Unclear risk | Unclear if outcome assessors were blinded. |
| Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | 8% attrition, but evenly distributed and ITT analysis used. |
| Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | All outcomes in protocol were reported on. |
| Other bias | Low risk | We identified no other sources of bias. |