Table 4.
Included study | Phase 2 | Phase 3 | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. Study eligibility criteria | 2. Identification and selection of studies | 3. Data collection and study appraisal | 4. Synthesis and findings | Risk of bias in the review | |
Li [24] (2009) | |||||
Yan [19] (2015) | |||||
Yao [22] (2016) | |||||
Liang [41] (2016) | |||||
Chen [33] (2016) | |||||
An [38] (2016) | |||||
Luo [39] (2016) | ? | ||||
Liu [35] (2017) | |||||
Pu [28] (2017) | ? | ||||
Zhang [31] (2018) | |||||
Liang [32] (2018) | |||||
Zhu [21] (2018) | ? | ||||
Li [37] (2018) | ? | ||||
Wei [26] (2019) | ? | ||||
Zhao [40] (2019) | ? | ||||
Li [36] (2019) | |||||
Wu [29] (2019) | |||||
Zhao [30] (2019) | ? | ||||
Yao [20] (2019) | |||||
Zhao [27] (2020) | ? | ||||
Zhang [34] (2020) | |||||
Xiao [23] (2020) | |||||
Ke [25] (2021) |
Note: = low risk; = high risk; ? = unclear risk.