Table 1.
First author, publication year, country | Study design1 | Participants at baseline; number of females; mean age | Cancer location, stage | Intervention | Survival measure | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Verum | Control | Verum | Control | ||||
RCTs | |||||||
Brinkmann,15 2004, Germany2 | Single center | 37; 11; 63 | 37; 13; 62 | Renal cell, 3-4 | Eurixor | IFN-α 2b, IL-2, 5-FU | OS, RR |
Cazacu,20 2003, Romania | Single center, 3 arms | 29; n/a; n/a | B: 21; n/a; n/a; C:14; n/a; n/a | Colorectal, 3-43 | Isorel, 5-FU, surgery | B: 5-FU, surgery; C: surgery | OS |
Douwes,16 1986, Germany | Single center, 3 arms | 20; 10; 59 | B: 20; 12; 60; C: 20; 11; 61 | colorectal, 4 | Helixor, 5-FU | B: Neo-Tumorin, 5-FU; C: 5-FU | OS, RR |
Douwes,21 1988, Germany4 | Single center | 20; n/a; 60 | 20; n/a; 56 | Colorectal, 4 | Helixor, 5-FU | 5-FU | OS |
Goebell,22 2002, Germany | Single center | 23; 6; 65 | 22; 5; 65 | Bladder, 1-2 | Lektinol | No treatment | DFS |
Gutsch,17 1988, Germany3,4 | Multi center, 3 arms | 192; 192; 60 | B: 274; 274; 62; C: 177; 177; 62 | Breast, 1-3 | Helixor, ctx | B: ctx; C: no treatment | OS |
Heiny,23 1997, Germany | Single center | 38; 16; 55 | 41; 18; 53 | Colorectal, 4 | Eurixor, 5-FU | 5-FU | OS, RR, DFS |
Lange,24 1988, Germany | Single center | 23; 9; 58 | 21; 9; 60 | Ovary, lung, n/a | Helixor, ctx | ctx | RR, DR |
Lenartz,25 2000, Germany | Single center | 20; n/a; n/a | 18; n/a; n/a | Glioma, n/a | Eurixor, cot | cot | OS, DFS |
Steuer-Vogt,27 2001, Germany3 | Multi center | 235; 21; 55 | 242; 19; 55 | Head, neck, 1-4 | Eurixor, surgery, ctx | Surgery, ctx | DFS |
Tröger,26 2016, Serbia | Single center | 34; 34; 50 | 31; 31; 52 | Breast, 1-3 | Helixor, ctx | ctx | RR |
NRSIs | |||||||
Axtner,28 2016, Germany | Multi center | 90; 44; 66 | 105; 57; 68 | Pancreatic, 3-4 | uME, ctx | ctx | OS |
Beuth,29 2008, Germany | Multi center | 167; 167; 55 | 514; 514; 55 | Breast, 1-3 | Helixor, cot | cot | RR, DR |
Boie,30 1980, Germany | Multi center | 27; n/a; n/a | 39; n/a; n/a | Colorectal, n/a | Helixor | No treatment | OS, DR |
Elsässer-Beile,14 2005, Germany2 | Single center, prospective | 30; 7; 70 | 18; n/a; n/a | Bladder, 1-2 | Lektinol | Bacillus Calmette-Guerin | RR |
Prediger,31 1956, Germany | Single center | 75; 75; n/a | 88; 86; n/a | Genital, n/a | Lektinol, rt | rt | OS, DR |
Schad,32 2018, Germany | Multi center | 43; 18; 64 | 100; 43; 64 | Lung, 4 | uME, cot | cot | OS |
Schumacher,33 2003, Germany | Multi center | 219; 219; 60 | 470; 470; 64 | Breast, 1-4 | Eurixor, cot | cot | DFS |
Thronicke,34 2020, Germany | Multi center | 34; 17; 65 | 235; 95; 69 | Lung, 1-3a | uME, ctx | ctx | OS |
Abbreviations: OS, overall survival; RR, relapse rate; DFS, disease free survival; DR, death rate; cot, conventional oncological treatment; ctx, chemotherapy; rt, radiation therapy.
All studies are not blinded and with 2 arms if not stated otherwise, all RCTs are prospective; all NRSIs are retrospective if not stated otherwise.
This study compares uME with an active comparator and is only included in the sensitivity analysis.
Survival data for subgroups available.
Randomization process is reported as incomplete.