Table 3.
Trait dissociation – Study characteristics and results.
HR | HRV | BP | SC | ||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study | N | Patients | Mean age | Sex distribution (% women) | Dissociation measurement | Physiological parameter | Symptom provocation | Comparison Specification | HR | PEP | RMSSD | HF | LF | LF/HF-ratio | RSA | BP (s/d) |
SCL | SCR | NSCF |
Personalized trauma stimuli | |||||||||||||||||||
Bichescu-Burian et al. (2017) | 21 | BPD patients with comorbid PTSD | 23.86 | 100 | DES | HR, SCRa, SCRf | Personalized trauma-content | Correlation | •* | • | |||||||||
Castro-Chapman et al. (2018) | 134 | Veterans with combat exposure (on average moderate PTSD symptom severity) | 37.64 | 8 | DES | HR | Personalized trauma-content | Correlation | •* | ||||||||||
Halligan et al. (2006) | 61a | Assault survivors (41% met criteria for PTSD) | 39.0 | 46 | TDQ | HR | Personalized trauma-content | Correlation – full sample (n = 54) | •* | ||||||||||
Correlation – females (n = 25) | •* | ||||||||||||||||||
Correlation – males (n = 29) | •* | ||||||||||||||||||
Hauschildt et al. (2011) | 70 |
n = 26 trauma-exposed with PTSD, n = 26 trauma-exposed without PTSD, n = 18 non-exposed controls |
32.7b | 71 | DES | RMSSD, HF-HRV, LF-HRV | Video with emotional valence (neutral, negative, positive, trauma-related) | Correlation | • | • | • | ||||||||
Hyer et al. (1993) | 57 (n = 19 low diss., n = 17 medium diss., n = 21 high diss.) |
Veterans with chronic PTSD | 40.2 | 0 | DES | HR | Personalized trauma-content | High vs. medium dissociation | ↑ •* |
||||||||||
High vs. low dissociation | • •* |
||||||||||||||||||
Rhudy et al. (2008) | 28 | Trauma-exposed with chronic nightmares (32% current PTSD, 46% lifetime PTSD) | 39.0 | 68 | DES | HR, SCL | Personal nightmare scripts | Correlation | •* | •* | |||||||||
Schmahl et al. (2004) | 14 | PTSD patients with history of sexual & /or physical abuse | 36.2 | 100 | DES | HR, BP, NSCF | Personalized trauma-content | Correlation | •* | ↑*/•* | •* | ||||||||
Vermes et al. (2020) | 21 | PTSD patients | 34.7 | 95 | DES | SCR | Personalized trauma-content | Correlation | • | ||||||||||
General stress stimuli | |||||||||||||||||||
Powers et al. (2021) | 19 | Trauma-exposed with diabetes | 46.95 | 100 | MDI | HR, LF/HF-ratio, RSA | Trier Social Stress Test | Correlation | ↓ | • | • | ||||||||
Schäflein et al. (2018) | 18 | DDNOS patients with comorbid PTSD | 41.7 | 94 | DES | HR, lnRMSSD, PEP | mirror confrontation (only, or combined with positive or negative cognitions) | Correlation | • | • | • | ||||||||
Schalinski et al. (2013) | 31 | Refugees with multiple traumatic experiences & PTSD (6% did not meet the avoidance criterion) | 36.45 | 100 | Shut-D | HR | White noise | Correlation | • | ||||||||||
Seligowski et al. (2019) | 19 | General medical hospital in-patients with PTSD | 37.68 | 100 | MDI | HR, RSA, SCR | Fear-potentiated startle paradigm | Correlation | •* | •c* | ↓d | ||||||||
20 | Psychiatric hospital in-patients with PTSD | 39.75 | 100 | MID | Correlation | •* | •c* | ↑e | |||||||||||
Simeon et al. (2008) | 21 | New York City residents highly exposed to 9/11 (33% met criteria for PTSD) | 40.4 | 38 | DES | HR, BP | Trier Social Stress Test | Correlation | ↓ | • /• |
Note: Arrow directions indicate increase ↑ or decrease ↓ during provocation condition, parentheses indicate non-significant results, * = results indicated by change score, • = no effect. If studies reported results during condition and change scores, both are presented in the table; BP (s/d): (systolic or diastolic) blood pressure, BPD: Borderline Personality Disorder, DDNOS: Dissociative Disorder Not Otherwise Specified, DES: Dissociative Experience Scale, HF-HRV: high frequency heart rate variability, HR: heart rate, HRV: heart rate variability, LF-HRV: low frequency heart rate variability, LF/HF-ratio: ratio of low frequency to high frequency heart rate variability, lnRMSSD: natural logarithm of root mean square successive difference; MDI: Multiscale Dissociation Inventory, MID: Multidimensional Inventory of Dissociation, NSCF: number of skin conductance fluctuations, PEP: pre-ejection period, PTSD: Posttraumatic-Stress Disorder, RMSSD: root mean square successive difference, RSA: respiratory sinus arrhythmia, SC: skin conductance, SCL: skin conductance level, SCR: skin conductance response, SCRa: amplitude of skin conductance response, SCRf: frequency of skin conductance response, Shut-D: Shutdown Dissociation Scale, TDQ: Trait Dissociation Questionnaire.
a Correlation with trait dissociation is available for 54 participants.
bN-adjusted mean value weighted by size of subgroups.
cSignificant positive correlations were only found in trait dissociation subscales of depersonalization in the general hospital sample and derealization in the psychiatric sample.
For danger signal.
For safety signal.