Authors |
Cohort |
EVD? |
CSF infections |
LD revisions |
Number requiring a shunt |
Cerebral herniation post-ELD? |
Details |
Abadal Centellas et al., 2007 [29] |
n=17 (adults, TBI) |
No |
0 (3 contaminants) |
2 (5 blockages) |
0 |
n=0 |
No pupil changes in 24 hours post insertion |
Bauer et al., 2017 [31] |
n=8 (adults, TBI) |
No |
None stated |
None stated |
None stated |
n=1 |
One patient showed an uncal herniation on both sides after lumbar CSF withdrawal without mydriasis or other clinical signs of cerebral herniation |
Levy et al., 1995 [32] |
n=16 (children, TBI) |
Yes in all |
None stated |
None stated |
3 |
n=0 |
Two patients had fixed and dilated pupils prior to ELD insertion, remained so after lumbar drainage commenced |
Llompart Pou et al., 2011 [33] |
n=30 (adults, TBI) |
No |
1 (4 with positive cultures, 3 contaminant) |
4 (8 obstruction) |
3 |
n=0 |
No pupil changes in 48 hours post insertion |
Manet et al., 2016 [34] |
n=4 (adults, TBI) |
No |
0 |
0 |
0 |
n=0 |
N/A |
Manet et al., 2017 [35] |
n=33 (adults, TBI/SAH/ICH) |
Mixed (8/33) |
1 |
0 |
5 |
n=0 |
N/A |
Murad et al., 2012 [25] |
n=15 (adults, TBI/SAH) |
Yes in all |
0 |
None stated |
None stated |
n=1 |
Fixed dilated pupil four hours after ELD insertion, which returned to normal after surgery hours |
Tuettenberg et al., 2009 [23] |
n=100 (adults, TBI/SAH) |
Mixed (84/100) |
7 (all also had EVD) |
14/100 |
None stated |
n=12 |
No relationship to ELD described. All had unilateral mydriasis. 4/12 survived. Three patients died from cerebral herniation secondary to intracranial hypertension, three had a devastating injury prior to ELD, one died from pulmonary embolism, one died from cerebral infarction. No reports of morbidity or mortality directly from ELD |
Willemse, 1998 [37] |
n=7 (adults, TBI) |
Yes in all |
None stated |
None stated |
None stated |
n=0 |
N/A |