Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 24;13:1016737. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2022.1016737

Table 4.

Toxicity effect of various compounds against the second instar crawlers of P. lilacinus.

Percent mortality (mean ± SE) at different concentrations after 48 h
Compounds 5,000 ppm 2,500 ppm 1,250 ppm 625 ppm 312.5 ppm Pooled mean
1-Cyclohexyl-2-pyrrolidone 58 ± 8.37 48 ± 4.47 38 ± 10.95 26 ± 5.48 18 ± 4.47 37.60 ± 16.15 def
Camphene 56 ± 8.94 46 ± 11.40 36 ± 11.40 30 ± 10.00 20 ± 7.07 37.60 ± 15.62 def
Cinnamaldehyde 72 ± 8.37 50 ± 7.07 42 ± 8.37 34 ± 5.48 24 ± 8.94 44.40 ± 18.05 bcd
Citral 52 ± 8.37 40 ± 14.14 30 ± 12.25 22 ± 13.04 14 ± 5.48 31.60 ± 17.00 f
Geraniol 82 ± 8.37 60 ± 7.07 48 ± 13.04 32 ± 4.47 24 ± 5.48 49.20 ± 22.35 abc
L-carvone 70 ± 14.14 40 ± 7.07 30 ± 7.07 24 ± 5.48 16 ± 5.48 36.00 ± 20.62 def
L-limonene 76 ± 11.40 62 ± 4.47 56 ± 8.94 44 ± 5.48 34 ± 8.94 54.40 ± 16.60 a
L-menthol 80 ± 7.07 60 ± 10.00 52 ± 4.47 36 ± 5.48 28 ± 13.04 51.20 ± 20.27 ab
β-myrcene 68 ± 8.37 50 ± 10.00 40 ± 12.25 34 ± 5.48 24 ± 11.40 43.20 ± 17.73 bcde
Ocimene 68 ± 16.43 42 ± 8.37 32 ± 13.04 24 ± 5.48 10 ± 10.00 35.20 ± 22.38 ef
α-terpinene 62 ± 10.95 54 ± 16.73 40 ± 10.00 34 ± 11.40 18 ± 8.37 41.60 ± 19.08 cde
β-terpinene 56 ± 13.42 48 ± 8.37 42 ± 16.43 34 ± 15.17 28 ± 10.95 41.60 ± 15.73 cde
Pooled mean 66.67 ± 1.27 a 50 ± 1.27 b 40.50 ± 1.27 c 31.17 ± 1.27 d 21.50 ± 1.27 e
Compounds F 11, 299 = 12.45; p < 0.0001
Concentrations F 4, 299 = 189.09; p < 0.0001
Compound × Concentrations F 44, 299 = 0.93; p > 0.05

Mean of five replications: Means followed by the same letters within a column are not statistically significant (p > 0.05) by Tukey’s HSD.