Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 4;36(12):8737–8752. doi: 10.1007/s00464-022-09421-5

Table 5.

Summarized Modified Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) critical appraisal checklist

Item Checklist Applicability
1 A clear objective and description of inclusion criteria of the medical images/videos 52% (12/23)
2 A detailed description of the study population (how are patients recruited, which operation, laparoscopy/robotic surgery, (dataset)) 65% (15/23)
3 A clear description of the data source and how data were collected (method of measurement, machine used, manual annotation, reproducible measurements) 65% (15/23)
4 A valid and reproducible data collection and measurement method 39% (9/23)
5 Attainment of ethical approval? 52% (12/23)
6 Were findings and implications discussed in detail? 87% (20/23)
7 Were the outcomes (performance and result of ML tools) measured in a valid and reliable way? 74% (17/23)
8 Was appropriate cross-validation and evaluation method used? 61% (14/23)