Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 27;23(21):13040. doi: 10.3390/ijms232113040

Table 2.

Different chemical methods used for cardiac tissue decellularization.

Chemical Decellularization Techniques Mechanism General Disadvantages Study Findings
Ionic detergents (SDS)
  • breaks non-covalent bonds

  • aggressive treatment

  • cytotoxic; it requires vigorous rinsing

  • no intact cells or nuclei were detected in 1% SDS-treated rat hearts for 12 h, with preserved fiber composition and orientation [11]

  • perfusion of porcine hearts with 4% SDS for 12 h lacked intracellular components but retained specific collagen fibers, proteoglycan, elastin, and mechanical integrity [16]

  • decellularization of porcine hearts by repeated washing with 0.5% SDS resulted in 98% DNA removal with only 6 h of detergent exposure [18]

  • 9 h treatment with 0.5% SDS of human left ventricular myocardium showed a pronounced reduction of major matrix components compared to the 3-step protocol (2 h lysis, 6 h 0.5% SDS, and 3 h FBS) [21]

  • 24 h of 0.1% SDS treatment of porcine valve conduits was reported to be effective in cell removal but susceptible to recellularization with human cells [83]

  • low SDS concentration for a limited time (0.5% SDS, 5.5 h) delivered acellular heart constructs (13.1 ± 5.8 ng/mg residual DNA) with maintained cytocompatibility (reseeded with human bone marrow-MSCs) [84]

  • porcine aortic and pulmonary roots treated with different concentrations of SDS removed cells completely but caused strong structural alterations [93]

  • an optimized 1% SDS-based decellularization protocol obtained acellular cardiac scaffolds with applicability to generate vascularized cardiac patches [94]

Non-ionic detergents (Triton X-100)
  • solubilizes cell membranes, disrupting lipid-lipid and lipid-protein connections

  • less effective in removing cellular debris

  • rat hearts treated with Triton X-100 for 12 h showed incomplete decellularization [11]

  • decellularization of porcine hearts with 3% Triton X-100 resulted in incomplete decellularization with only 40% DNA removal [79]

  • 48 h treatment with 5% Triton X-100 damaged the tissue architecture of the human myocardium but was not sufficient to remove cellular material [21]

Acids and bases
  • solubilize cytoplasmic elements, disrupting nucleic acids

  • frequently aggressive toward the proteins of the ECM

  • mainly used in combination with other decellularization agents

  • PAA increases ECM stiffness

  • submillimeter diameter vascular scaffolds decellularized with 0.3% PAA proved patent in rat allogeneic transplantation model for 2 weeks, followed by graft rupture [86]

  • bovine pericardium pretreatment by reversible alkaline swelling (RAS) produced a severe reduction in GAGs and stress relaxation ratios [87]

Hypertonic and hypotonic treatments
  • induce cell lysis by osmotic shock

  • inadequate cellular removal

  • ineffective for whole organ decellularization

  • hyper/hypotonic treatment alone for 72 h of human myocardium damaged the ECM and showed incomplete decellularization [21]

Organic solvents (ethanol)
  • dehydrates and lyses cells

  • potential damage to the ECM microstructure

  • ethanol pretreatment of bioprosthetic heart valves led to unexpectedly cuspal calcification [92]