Table 7.
Alternative evaluation matrix
C11 | C12 | C13 | C14 | C15 | C16 | C21 | C22 | C23 | C24 | C31 | C32 | C33 | C34 | C41 | C42 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
EXPERT-1 | A-1 | G | MG | G | G | G | MG | VG | G | G | MG | MG | G | F | MG | G | G |
A-2 | VG | G | G | G | G | VG | VG | G | MG | MG | G | G | G | MG | G | G | |
A-3 | G | MG | G | MG | G | VG | G | G | MG | MG | G | G | G | MG | G | VG | |
A-4 | G | B | G | B | MB | VG | MG | MB | MG | F | MG | G | MG | MG | G | G | |
A-5 | VG | F | G | B | MG | VG | G | MB | MG | F | MG | G | G | MG | G | G | |
C43 | C44 | C45 | C46 | C51 | C52 | C53 | C54 | C55 | C56 | C61 | C62 | C63 | C64 | C65 | C66 | ||
A-1 | G | MG | MG | G | G | MG | G | MG | G | MG | G | MG | G | G | MG | MG | |
A-2 | G | G | VG | VG | MG | VG | VG | G | B | VG | G | MG | G | G | VG | G | |
A-3 | VG | G | VG | VG | F | VG | VG | VG | MG | VG | MG | MG | G | G | VG | VG | |
A-4 | MG | G | VG | MG | MB | G | MG | MG | MB | G | MG | MG | G | G | G | G | |
A-5 | MG | G | VG | G | MB | VG | G | VG | B | VG | MG | MG | G | G | G | G | |
C11 | C12 | C13 | C14 | C15 | C16 | C21 | C22 | C23 | C24 | C31 | C32 | C33 | C34 | C41 | C42 | ||
EXPERT-2 | A-1 | MB | MG | B | MG | F | G | MG | F | G | F | F | G | MG | VB | F | VG |
A-2 | VG | MG | MG | G | MG | G | F | F | MG | F | MG | G | G | MB | G | MG | |
A-3 | G | VG | VG | MG | G | VG | VG | F | G | G | G | MB | G | B | VG | VG | |
A-4 | B | VB | MG | VB | VB | VG | MG | MB | B | B | B | B | B | VB | G | G | |
A-5 | B | VB | MB | VB | B | VG | F | B | B | B | MB | B | MB | MB | VG | MB | |
C43 | C44 | C45 | C46 | C51 | C52 | C53 | C54 | C55 | C56 | C61 | C62 | C63 | C64 | C65 | C66 | ||
A-1 | MG | B | F | MG | MB | MG | MG | F | G | MG | MG | B | F | F | MB | MG | |
A-2 | G | VG | G | VG | MB | VG | MG | G | MB | G | G | MG | MG | MB | G | G | |
A-3 | MG | MG | VG | VG | MB | VG | G | VG | MG | G | G | G | G | MB | VG | VG | |
A-4 | MG | MG | G | G | VB | MG | MG | MB | G | G | MG | MG | F | G | MB | MB | |
A-5 | F | G | VG | G | VB | VG | VG | VG | VG | G | F | F | G | F | MG | G | |
C11 | C12 | C13 | C14 | C15 | C16 | C21 | C22 | C23 | C24 | C31 | C32 | C33 | C34 | C41 | C42 | ||
EXPERT-3 | A-1 | G | G | F | MG | MG | MB | F | F | MB | G | G | F | F | F | G | G |
A-2 | G | G | G | F | MG | F | MG | F | B | G | MG | MG | F | MB | F | B | |
A-3 | F | VG | VG | MG | G | F | VG | VG | VG | VG | VB | B | MB | MG | MG | VG | |
A-4 | MB | MB | MB | MB | F | G | F | MB | MB | F | MB | MB | F | F | MG | G | |
A-5 | MG | VB | B | MB | MB | VG | MB | B | B | F | B | MB | F | F | MB | MB | |
C43 | C44 | C45 | C46 | C51 | C52 | C53 | C54 | C55 | C56 | C61 | C62 | C63 | C64 | C65 | C66 | ||
A-1 | G | B | MB | B | MB | MB | MG | MB | G | MB | G | MB | MG | MG | MB | MG | |
A-2 | VG | VG | F | G | F | MG | G | MG | B | G | MG | MG | MB | MB | MG | G | |
A-3 | G | G | G | F | B | VG | B | VG | MG | VG | MG | G | B | VB | VG | VG | |
A-4 | F | F | G | MG | MB | F | F | F | MB | F | MG | F | MB | F | F | B | |
A-5 | B | F | VG | MG | G | VG | G | VG | MG | VG | MB | F | F | MB | MG | MG | |
C11 | C12 | C13 | C14 | C15 | C16 | C21 | C22 | C23 | C24 | C31 | C32 | C33 | C34 | C41 | C42 | ||
EXPERT-4 | A-1 | F | MB | F | F | F | MB | G | G | MB | F | B | F | B | F | F | F |
A-2 | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | MG | G | G | G | VG | G | MB | |
A-3 | G | G | MG | MG | MG | MG | MG | MG | MG | G | MG | MG | MG | MB | VG | MG | |
A-4 | VB | VB | MB | MB | MB | F | MB | MB | F | MB | F | B | VB | MG | MG | VG | |
A-5 | B | B | G | G | G | G | F | F | G | B | MB | MB | MB | G | MB | G | |
C43 | C44 | C45 | C46 | C51 | C52 | C53 | C54 | C55 | C56 | C61 | C62 | C63 | C64 | C65 | C66 | ||
A-1 | F | MG | MB | MB | MB | F | MB | F | MB | F | F | MB | MB | MB | MB | F | |
A-2 | G | VG | G | MG | G | G | VG | G | F | G | G | G | G | G | G | VG | |
A-3 | MG | G | VG | VG | MG | VG | G | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | VG | G | |
A-4 | MB | MB | MG | G | F | MB | MG | MB | MG | MB | MB | F | F | F | F | MB | |
A-5 | B | F | F | F | B | MG | F | MG | G | MG | MG | MG | MG | MG | MG | MG |