Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 14;378(1867):20210074. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2021.0074

Table 1.

Description of the general stand-age effect and the interactions of stand age with precipitation, clay type (low versus high activity), clay concentration (%), previous land-use type (cropland versus pasture) and soil depth (upper 0–15 cm versus lower 15–30 cm) on the resistance of soil properties (i.e. the difference between old-growth and agriculture) and the recovery of soil properties (i.e. the change with stand age). Empty cells for the interaction effects indicate non-significant effects. Note that the main effects of precipitation, clay type, clay concentration, previous land-use type and soil depth were also included in the model, but not explained here (but see electronic supplementary material, appendix S9 for statistics).

soil property resistance / recovery stand age stand age × precipitation stand age × clay type stand age × clay conc. stand age × previous land-use type stand age × soil depth
bulk density resistance (change from old-growth to agriculture) general increase increase at high-activity clay increase in pastures increase in deeper soil layer
recovery (change during succession) general decrease stronger decrease in high-activity clay stronger decrease at high clay conc. stronger decrease in upper soil layer
pH resistance (change from old-growth to agriculture) decrease or no change decreases in pastures
recovery (change during succession) decrease or no change decreases at low rainfall, no change at high rainfall
C resistance (change from old-growth to agriculture) general decrease decrease in high-activity clay, weak change in low-activity clay decrease in croplands, weak change in pastures
recovery (change during succession) general increase increase in high-activity clay, no change in low-activity clay increase in croplands, no change in pastures increase in upper soil layer, no change in lower soil layer
N resistance (change from old-growth to agriculture) general decrease decrease at high precipitation, no change at low precipitation decrease in high-activity clay, weak change in low-activity clay decrease in croplands, weak change in pastures
recovery (change during succession) general increase increase at high precipitation, no change at low precipitation increase in high-activity clay, no change in low-activity clay increase in croplands, no change in pasture increase in upper soil layer, no change in lower soil layer
C : N resistance (change from old-growth to agriculture) increase or no change increase at high precipitation, no change at low precipitation
recovery (change during succession) decrease or no change decrease at high precipitation, no change at low precipitation
P resistance (change from old-growth to agriculture) increase or no change increase in upper soil layer, no change in lower soil layer
recovery (change during succession) decrease or no change decrease at high clay concentration, no change at low clay conc.