Table 1.
Characteristics of studies included in the systematic review.
Author | Year | Location | Study | Participants | Sample | Intervention | Tools | Outcomes | P value |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alamolhoda [14] | 2019 | Iran | RCT | Primiparous with breast soreness and irritation |
G1= 55 G2= 55 |
Group 1= 0.5 ml Aloe vera gel/three times/Day Group2: breast milk |
Pain= visual analog scale Irritation= store scale |
Nipple pain, irritation, discharge follow up = 10, 14 days | P < 0.001 |
| |||||||||
Meng [25] | 2015 | China | RCT | Patients with puerperal milk stasis |
G1= 50 G2= 52 G3= 50 |
G1 = breast massage with cactus + Aloe vera cold compress G2= Aloe vera cold compress G3= traditional breast massage | Pain= visual analog scale | Pain and hardness follow up = after the treatments | P < 0.001 |
| |||||||||
Eshgizade [26] | 2016 | Iran | RCT | Patients with nipple fissure | G1= 30 G2= 30 G3= 30 |
G1= 0.5 ml olive oil G2= 0.5 ml Aloe vera extract + 3–4 drop breast milk/3 times/day G3= 3–4 drop breast milk |
Pain= visual analog scale Irritation= store scale |
Pain and intensity of breast fissure follow up = 3, 7 days | P < 0.001 |
| |||||||||
Sari [23] | 2021 | Indonesia | Quasi-experimental | Patient with breast engorgement |
G1= 17 G2= 17 |
G1= Aloe vera cold compress G2= control |
Pain= visual analog scale | Pain follow up = after the treatments | P < 0.01 |
| |||||||||
Susanti [24] | 2017 | Indonesia | Quasi-experimental | Patient with breast engorgement |
G1= 16 G= 16 |
G1= Aloe vera cold compress G2= control |
Pain= visual analog scale | Pain follow up = after the treatments | P < 0.01 |
| |||||||||
Tafazoli [4] | 2009 | Iran | RCT | Patient with breast soreness and irritation |
G1= 50 G1= 50 |
G1= Aloe vera gel/three times/day G2= lanolin |
Store scale = irritation = store scale | Irritation, follow up = 3, 7 days | P < 0.01 |
| |||||||||
Saeidi [27] | 2015 | Iran | RCT | Patient with breast soreness and irritation |
G1= 50 G1= 50 |
G1 = Aloe vera gel/three times/day G2= lanolin |
Store scale = irritation = store scale | Irritation, follow up = 3, 7 days | P < 0.01 |