Table 5.
Characteristics | Quality assessment | Summary of findings | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N. of subjects | Results | |||||||||
Fist author, year | Sport | Source of cases | Reference population | Exposure | Selection | Comparability | Outcome/exposure | n. cases among the exposed/total exposed | n. cases among the reference group/total reference | Data ORs/HRs (95%CIs) or SIRs/PRs/SMRs/SPMRs |
Cohort studies | ||||||||||
Bieniek 2019 [80] |
Baseball Basketball Boxing American football Hockey Soccer Wrestling |
Mayo Clinic Tissue Registry | consecutive autopsies from the Mayo Clinic Tissue Registry with available information on sport participation | information on sport participation and participation age/level/duration taken from high school yearbooks or obituaries | *** | – | *** |
300 athletes CTE positive:r 15 athletes CTE features: 12 |
450 non-athletes CTE positive: 6 CTE features: 9 |
OR* for combined CTE pathology (males) adj for age at death, baseball, boxing, and American football American football beyond high school OR = 13.23 (4.23, 41.36) p < 0.001 OR for combined CTE positive (CTE +) (males) adj for boxing and American football boxing OR = 10.29 (1.79, 59.28) p = 0.009 American football OR = 2.87 (1.17, 7.01) p = 0.021 American football beyond high school OR = 6.84 (1.76, 26.66) p = 0.0056 |
OR odds ratio
*Only adjusted data reporting statistically significant differences have been reported