5. Yoga intervention – type, components and design a.
Study | Type of yoga | Components of yoga intervention | How yoga intervention was designed |
Bramberg 2017 | Kundalini yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Mental focus |
Quote: "A prestructured standardized kundalini yoga programme adapted for back pain was used." |
Cox 2010 | Iyengar yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Mental focus |
Quote: "[D]evised by an iyengar yoga teacher (IYAUK) and LBP [low back pain] yoga specialist, in collaboration with a British Wheel of Yoga teacher (BWY), who delivered the intervention. The structure was based on that previously used in the US Karen Sherman yoga trial, … whilst ensuring that a common ground was found between the two associations of IYAUK and BWY. Other influences included Geeta and B.K.S. iyengar, who has taught yoga for over 70 years and has applied therapeutic variations of classical poses to many health problems including LBP." |
Demirel 2019 | — | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Philosophy |
— |
Galantino 2004 | Hatha yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Ethics (Yamas and Niyamas) |
Quote: "An expert panel of two hatha yoga instructors with greater than 10 years of experience and a physical therapist specializing in spine treatment established an initial yoga protocol for this study. Postures were selected based on orthopedic biomechanics." |
Groessl 2017 | Hatha yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Meditation Mental focus |
Quote: "[T]he yoga intervention that will be tested in the proposed RCT [randomized controlled trial] will be very similar to the yoga currently provided in the clinical yoga program that has been specifically tailored to the needs of veterans with CLBP [chronic low back pain]." Comment: unclear how program was developed. |
Highland 2018 | "Based on therapeutic yoga" | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Meditation |
Quote: "Yoga‐treatment researchers and experts developed a 50‐hour RESTORE yoga teacher training program. RESTORE is based on therapeutic yoga, targeting major muscles affected by chronic LBP [low back pain],… including back and core strengthening/stretching for postural alignment." |
Jacobs 2004 | Iyengar style of hatha yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Mental focus |
Comment: a panel of experts developed the yoga intervention. Quote: "The panel included 8 senior iyengar yoga instructors of national and international recognition with greater than 10 years experience teaching yoga. The protocol was constructed by consensus after 2 meetings and several months of discussion." |
Kuvacic 2018 | — | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation (Yoga Nidra) Meditation (Vipassana) |
Quote: "Contemporary yoga practices suited to CLBP [chronic low back pain]." |
Nambi 2014 | Iyengar yoga | Postures (Asanas) Relaxation |
— |
Neyaz 2019 | "Integrated yoga therapy module … developed from traditional hatha practices" | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Meditation Yoga philosophy |
Quote: "An integrated Yoga therapy module for CNLBP was developed from traditional hatha yoga practices, in collaboration with CIMR [Centre for Integrative Medicine and Research]." |
Patil 2018 | Integrated approach of yoga therapy (IAYT) | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Meditation |
Quote: "A 1h integrated yoga therapy module (IYTM) was designed after reviewing the literature in the field of yoga and LBP by utilizing the components of yoga at the body, subtle energy, and mind level, respectively. The designed IYTM was validated by subject experts." |
Saper 2009 | Hatha yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation |
Quote: "To design the protocol, we performed a systematic search of the peer‐reviewed and lay literature on yoga for low back pain. We collected and distributed this literature to an expert panel with a broad range of experience in different yoga styles. After reviewing the literature, the panel met and synthesized information from the literature with their professional experience to draft a protocol that was subsequently refined iteratively through discussion, consensus, and use in nonstudy yoga classes." |
Saper 2017 | Hatha yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Yoga philosophy |
Quote: "A manualized yoga protocol of 12 weekly 75‐minute classes was adapted from previous studies in similar populations with input from expert yoga instructors, investigators, and former study participants (Table 2 of Supplement 2)." |
Sherman 2005 | Viniyoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Mental focus |
Quote: "Our class instructor and a senior teacher of viniyoga, who has written a book about its therapeutic uses …, designed the yoga intervention for patients with back pain who did not have previous yoga experience." |
Sherman 2011 | Viniyoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation |
Used intervention developed by the class instructor and senior viniyoga teacher for previous trial. The developers are named and acknowledged in the protocol publication for this trial. |
Tekur 2008 | 'Integrated Approach of Yoga Therapy (IAYT)' | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Meditation Mental focus Chanting Yoga philosophy/lifestyle |
Quote: "The specific 'integrated yoga therapy module for low back pain' was developed by a team of two yoga experts and a physiatrist. The concepts of the modules were taken from traditional yoga scriptures (patanjali yoga sutra, and yoga vasishtha) that highlight a holistic approach to health management at physical, mental, emotional and intellectual levels." |
Teut 2016 | Viniyoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Concentration |
Quote: "The classes were developed by a group of experienced viniyoga teachers during a consensus process." |
Tilbrook 2011 | Iyengar and British Wheel of Yoga (described as hatha yoga on the website) | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Relaxation Mental focus Yoga philosophy/lifestyle |
Quote from protocol publication: "Within the first three months of the study, whilst we gain ethics permission and NHS Research and Development approval, we will conduct a series of meetings between experienced yoga practitioners in order to agree on a basic package of yoga that can be delivered by yoga teachers of these two national organisations [British Wheel of Yoga and Iyengar Yoga Association (UK)]." |
Wattamwar 2013 | Combination of iyengar and traditional yoga | Postures (Asanas) Breathing (Pranayama) Prayer |
— |
Williams 2005 | Iyengar yoga | Postures (Asanas) | Quote: "The yoga intervention was developed with the consultation of senior iyengar yoga instructors who had experience with iyengar's protocol for treating CLBP [chronic low back pain]. The principal investigator, an iyengar student for 14 years and teacher in training for 9 years, was introduced to the protocol for CLBP by Geeta Iyengar at Ramamani Memorial Institute in Pune, India in 1998. Since then she has utilized this therapeutic protocol and studied under senior iyengar teachers with a minimum of 25 years of experience." |
Williams 2009 | Iyengar yoga | Postures (Asanas) | Quote: "The yoga therapy was developed in collaboration with 2 senior iyengar teachers and approved by B. K. S. Iyengar." |
aAll information is as explicitly described in study publication(s) or report(s).