Table 5. Comparison of QSAR Conclusions of Persistency with Those of Reported Simulated Half-Lives in Water, Soil, and Sediment and the REACH Annex XIII Criteria for Persistence (P) And Very Persistent (vP)a.
comparison of QSAR conclusions with simulation test half-life conclusions | QSAR max t1/2 | n | |
---|---|---|---|
t1/2-QSAR | P in water, soil OR sediment agrees with t1/2-QSAR ≥ 40 days | 74% | 78 |
”Not P” in water, soil AND sediment agrees with t1/2-QSAR < 40 days | 40% | 5 | |
overall efficiency | 72% | 83 | |
OPERA | P in water, soil, OR sediment agrees with OPERA ≥ 40 days | 19% | 72 |
”Not P” in water, soil, AND sediment agrees with OPERA < 40 days | 100% | 3 | |
overall efficiency | 23% | 75 | |
QSARToolbox | P in water, soil, OR sediment agrees with QSARToolbox profiler | 78% | 55 |
“Not P” in water, soil, AND sediment agrees with the QSARToolbox profiler | 50% | 4 | |
overall efficiency | 76% | 59 |
There are fewer predictions for not Persistent (Not P) as this comparison was required for simulated half-lives in all water, soil, and sediment media. Overall efficiency refers to the frequency of times P and “Not P” were predicted correctly.