Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 6;40(12):1207–1220. doi: 10.1007/s40273-022-01191-1

Table 3.

Predicted outcomes and health economic results from age 30 years by strategy

No screening Screen 50 Screen 70 Screen 60 Risk-stratified 4 yearly to age 70 years Risk stratified 2 yearly to age 70 years Adaptive screening at age 50–70 years, interval of 6 years if PSA level < 1.5 ng/mL, 4 years if >1.5 ng/mL Repeat screen every 4 years at age 50–70 years Repeat screen every 2 years at age 50–70 years
Outcomes per 10,000 mena
Number of screens 0 8285 7029 7978 6173 10,049 31,155 40,223 65,335
Number of MRI events 0 96 1022 627 834 1205 2458 2423 3519
Number of screen-initiated biopsies 0 64 631 400 538 750 1471 1452 2013
Number of clinically initiated biopsies 2817 2752 2474 2491 2390 2295 1925 1942 1826
Diagnosed PCa 1487 1488 1547 1509 1538 1555 1583 1582 1600
Screen diagnosis 0 36 245 195 278 345 569 558 636
Metastatic cancer 254 248 217 226 215 207 173 174 167
Localised and G <6 702 705 757 731 757 774 805 803 823
Localised and G = 7 292 296 313 308 313 318 336 336 339
Localised and G >7 238 239 260 244 252 256 268 269 271
Overdiagnosis 0 2 60 22 51 68 97 95 113
PCa death 527 520 512 504 497 489 457 459 444
Life-years, QALYs, costs, ICERs and NMB per man. Strategies sorted by increasing costsa
Life years (undiscounted) 51.5370 51.5506 51.5515 51.5671 51.5707 51.5785 51.6237 51.6212 51.6388
Life-years, 3.5% discounted 23.5624 23.5652 23.5646 23.5676 23.5680 23.5692 23.5775 23.5771 23.5801
QALYs (undiscounted) 42.518 42.527 42.519 42.534 42.532 42.535 42.560 42.559 42.567
QALYs, 3.5% discounted 20.2428 20.2442 20.2419 20.2440 20.2431 20.2429 20.2452 20.2450 20.2451
NHS costs, undiscounted 2013 2042 2152 2117 2161 2224 2414 2424 2610
NHS costs, 3.5% discounted (£) 449 466 488 493 506 528 609 613 685
ICER £12,860 Dominated Extendedly dominated Extendedly dominated Extendedly dominated £137,364 Dominated Extendedly dominated
Net monetary benefit (£20k)b 404,408 404,417 404,351 404,386 404,356 404,329 404,296 404,286 404,217
Net monetary benefit (£30k)b 606,836 606,859 606,771 606,826 606,787 606,758 606,748 606,735 606,668

G Gleason score, ICER incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, MRI magnetic resonance imaging, NHS National Health Service, NMB net monetary benefit, PCa prostate cancer, QALYs quality-adjusted life-years

aBased on life histories of 10 million simulated men

bStrategy with the highest net monetary benefit highlighted in bold