Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 7;13:996220. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2022.996220

TABLE 1.

Effect of graded B levels on soil physico-chemical properties at different crop stages in cauliflower-cowpea-okra cropping system (Pooled data 2015–017).

B-levels (kg ha–1) Bulk density (BD)
Soil pH
Soil organic carbon (%)
Available N
Available P
Vegetative stage
Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra
B0 1.24a 1.23a 1.22a 4.83a 4.87a 4.82a 0.90a 0.95a 0.91a 301.20d 311.50d 304.73d 15.95c 18.13c 20.31c
B0.5 1.23a 1.22a 1.21a 4.85a 4.88a 4.85a 0.95a 1.01a 0.94a 307.25c 318.65c 310.95c 17.00bc 19.50bc 21.33bc
B1.0 1.24a 1.23a 1.21a 4.87a 4.88a 4.86a 0.99a 1.01a 0.97a 314.91bc 324.6b 317.61bc 17.98ab 20.58b 22.45ab
B1.5 1.23a 1.22a 1.22a 4.86a 4.89a 4.85a 1.01a 1.02a 0.99a 322.56b 329.95b 324.76b 18.95ab 21.55b 23.41ab
B2.0 1.23a 1.22a 1.21a 4.86a 4.89a 4.85a 1.01a 1.04a 1.00a 328.06a 335.35a 329.83a 20.03a 22.63a 24.70a
Mean 1.23 1.22 1.21 4.85 4.88 4.85 0.97 1.01 0.96 314.80 324.01 317.58 17.98 20.48 22.44

Reproductive stage in different crops*
Cauliflower
Cowpea
Okra
Cauliflower
Cowpea
Okra
Cauliflower
Cowpea
Okra
Cauliflower
Cowpea
Okra
Cauliflower
Cowpea
Okra
Cis Fls Frs Cis Fls Frs Cis Fls Frs Cis Fls Frs Cis Fls Frs

B0 1.24a 1.23a 1.22a 4.81a 4.86a 4.84a 0.86a 0.92a 0.89a 301.30d 307.33cd 302.63c 15.63c 15.49c 18.98c
B0.5 1.23a 1.23a 1.21a 4.84a 4.87a 4.85a 0.91a 0.94a 0.92a 306.85bc 313.20c 308.55bc 16.59bc 16.50bc 20.02bc
B1.0 1.24a 1.23a 1.21a 4.84a 4.87a 4.85a 0.95a 0.96a 0.93a 313.51bc 318.37ab 315.31bc 17.54ab 17.57b 20.99bc
B1.5 1.24a 1.23a 1.21a 4.85a 4.87a 4.85a 0.98a 0.97a 0.95a 319.66b 323.55ab 321.20b 18.52ab 18.62b 22.00b
B2.0 1.23a 1.22a 1.21a 4.85a 4.86a 4.86a 1.02a 0.97a 0.95a 324.87a 328.89a 326.17a 19.45a 19.65a 23.07a
Mean 1.24 1.23 1.21 4.84 4.87 4.85 0.94 0.95 0.93 313.24 318.27 253.06 17.55 17.57 21.01

Maturity stage
Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra Cauliflower Cowpea Okra

B0 1.24a 1.24a 1.22a 4.82a 4.85a 4.86a 0.82a 0.93a 0.91a 296.40d 300.82d 299.10c 14.89c 15.37c 17.65c
B0.5 1.23a 1.22a 1.21a 4.83a 4.85a 4.87a 0.84a 0.95a 0.92a 302.00c 307.03cd 304.70bc 15.97ab 16.52bc 18.72b
B1.0 1.23a 1.23a 1.22a 4.83a 4.86a 4.87a 0.85a 0.95a 0.93a 308.11bc 312.53c 310.81bc 16.94ab 17.44ab 19.73b
B1.5 1.22a 1.23a 1.21a 4.84a 4.86a 4.87a 0.85a 0.96a 0.93a 312.76b 317.54b 315.46b 17.87a 18.39ab 20.69ab
B2.0 1.22a 1.23a 1.21a 4.84a 4.86a 4.88a 0.86a 0.97a 0.94a 317.56a 323.01a 320.26a 18.81a 19.41a 21.84a
Mean 1.23 1.23 1.21 4.83 4.86 4.87 0.84 0.95 0.93 307.37 312.19 310.07 16.90 17.43 19.73

*Cis, curd initiation stage in cauliflower; Fls, flowering stage in cowpea; Frs, fruiting stage in okra. The means followed by a different letter are significantly different at p ≤ 0.05 by Duncan’s multiple range test (values are means of 3-replicates).