Table 2.
Published randomized controlled studies on laparoscopic versus open PD
| Name of study and author | Year | Country | Study design | Number of patients included | Inclusion criteria | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
PLOT Palanivelu et al. [37] |
2017 | India | Single-center, non-blinded RCT | 32 LPD vs. 32 OPD |
All malignancies requiring a PD Patients aged 30–70 years |
Shorter hospital stays for LPD More blood loss and higher surgical site infection for OPD |
|
PADULAP Poves et al. [38] |
2018 | Spain | Single-center, non-blinded RCT | 34 LPD vs. 32 OPD |
All conditions (benign or malignant) requiring a PD Patients aged 18 years or older |
Reduced major morbidity and shorter LOS for LPD No differences in oncological outcomes |
|
LEOPARD-2 van Hilst et al. [39] |
2019 | The Netherlands | Multicenter, patient-blinded RCT | 50 LPD vs. 49 OPD |
All conditions (benign and malignant) requiring a PD Patients aged 18 years or older |
Higher mortality rate for LPD |
| Wang et al. [40] | 2021 | China | Multicenter, non-blinded RCT | 297 LPD vs. 297 OPD |
All conditions (benign and malignant) requiring a PD Patients aged 18–75 years |
Shorter hospital stay for LPD Longer operative time, less blood loss and fewer blood transfusions for LPD Mobilization, oral food intake, and removal of nasogastric tube all happened 1 day earlier for LPD |