Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 10;13:983352. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2022.983352

TABLE 2.

Data extraction and quality assessment.

References Author Type of participant Sample size Age mean, SD Measure Environmental features Setting Quality score
[41] Kim GW et al. 2010 Volunteer 28 26.9, 1.2 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[42] Kim TH et al. 2010 Volunteer 30 27,3.7 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[43] Seiyama et al. 2018 Volunteer 11 23.4,1.2 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.86
[44] Martínez-Soto 2013 Volunteer 28 36.18,12.46 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.73
[46] Kuhn et al. 2021 Volunteer 24 28.5, 9.5 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.95
[47] Bratman et al. 2015 Volunteer 38 26.7 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[48] Tang et al. 2017 Volunteer 31 25 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.86
[49] Zhang et al. 2019 Volunteer 16 20.5,1.71 fMRI Natural environment Indoor 0.86
[50] Chang et al. 2021 Volunteer 44 23.7 fMRI Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[51] Tost et al 2019 Volunteer 33 23.64,2.42 fMRI Natural environment Hybrid 0.86
[52] Heller 2020 Volunteer 122 23,3.4 fMRI Built and Natural environment Hybrid 0.91
[17] Lederbogen et al. 2011 Volunteer 55 N/A fMRI N/A Indoor 0.77
[56] Reed et al. 2020 Volunteer 487 31.9,8.9 fMRI N/A Indoor 0.82
[57] Lemmers-Jansen et al. 2020 Clinical 69 21.5,2.9 fMRI N/A Indoor 0.86
[58] Yamashita et al. 2021 Volunteer 25 23, 1.67 NIRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[59] Song et al. 2018 Volunteer 17 21.1 NIRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.77
[60] Lee 2017 Volunteer 18 26.7,0.7 NIRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.82
[61] Jo et al 2019 Volunteer 29 22.3,2.1 NIRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.95
[62] Ochiai et al. 2020 Clinical 12 36.9,11.5 NIRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.68
[63] Yu et al. 2017 Volunteer 7 36.3,11.3 NIRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.77
[64] Zhang et al. 2020 Volunteer 31 22.6, 1.4 NIRS Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[65] Park et al. 2007 Volunteer 12 22.8,1.4 TRS Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.77
[66] Joung et al. 2015 Volunteer 8 22,2.2 NIRS Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.82
[67] Song et al. 2020 Volunteer 29 21,1.4 NIRS Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.86
[68] Horiuchi et al. 2014 Volunteer 15 36 NIRS Natural environment Outdoor 0.86
[69] Ulrich 1981 Volunteer 18 23 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.77
[70] Elsadek et al. 2021 Elderly 34 82.9, 0.78 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.68
[71] Olszewska-Guizzo et al. 2018 Volunteer 29 31,10.3 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.86
[72] Jiang et al. 2019 Volunteer 50 22,1.65 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.73
[73] Roe et al. 2013 Volunteer 20 30 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.73
[74] Gao et al. 2019 Volunteer 116 20.7,2.13 EEG Built and Natural environment (VR) Indoor 0.95
[75] Mahamane et al. 2020 Volunteer 74 23 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.82
[77] Grassini et al. 2019 Volunteer 32 24.7,3.7 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[78] Kim et al. 2019 Volunteer 60 31 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[79] Elsadek et al. 2021 Elderly 34 82.9, 0.78 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.68
[80] Bailey et al. 2018 Volunteer 10 20 EEG Built and Natural environment Hybrid 0.68
[81] Olszewska-Guizzo et al. 2021 Volunteer 25 40,17.8 EEG Built and Natural environment Indoor 0.91
[82] Chiang et al. 2017 Volunteer 180 21.4,1.81 EEG Natural environment Indoor 0.82
[83] Wang et al. 2020 Volunteer 180 20.7,2.56 EEG Natural environment Indoor 0.68
[84] Chang et al. 2007 Volunteer 110 Not mentioned EEG Natural environment (VR) Indoor 0.82
[85] Olszewska-Guizzo 2018 Volunteer 32 27,6.5 EEG Natural environment Indoor 0.86
[86] Wang TC et al. 2020 Clinical 77 59.7 EEG Natural environment Indoor 0.68
[87] Rounds et al. 2020 Volunteer 29 27.65,10.04 EEG Built environment Indoor 0.86
[88] Hu et al. 2020 Volunteer 8 18.41,1.28 EEG Built environment Indoor 0.68
[89] Deng et al. 2019 Volunteer 60 20.8,1.02 EEG Natural environment Outdoor 0.77
[92] Herman et al. 2021 Volunteer 17 NA EEG Natural environment Outdoor 0.64
[93] Lin et al. 2019 Volunteer 240 20.2,1.76 EEG Natural environment Outdoor 0.95
[95] Lin et al. 2020 Volunteer 40 20.5,1.87 EEG Natural environment Hybrid 0.77
[96] Yi et al. 2021 Elderly 59 75,5 EEG Natural environment Outdoor 0.95
[98] Karandinou & Turner 2018 Volunteer 10 Not mentioned EEG Built environment Outdoor 0.45
[101] Hollander et al. 2016 Volunteer 5 Not mentioned EEG Built environment Outdoor 0.41
[103] Aspinall et al. 2013 Volunteer 12 30 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.59
[104] Al-barak et al. 2017 Volunteer 10 21 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.73
[105] Hassan et al. 2018 Volunteer 60 20,1.42 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.91
[106] Chen et al. 2016 Volunteer 32 20.6,1.6 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.86
[107] Reeves et al. 2019 Volunteer 36 41,11 M EEG Built and Natural environment Hybrid 0.82
[108] Olszewska-Guizzo et al. 2020 Volunteer 22 32.9,12.7 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.86
[110] Hopman et al. 2020 Volunteer 29 25,6.76 EEG Natural environment Outdoor 0.91
[112] Elsadek et al. 2019 Volunteer 25 23.5,1.5 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.95
[113] Tilley et al. 2017 Elderly 8 75.75,6.76 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.5
[114] Neale et al. 2017 Elderly 95 76,8.15 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.82
[116] Neale et al. 2020 Elderly 95 76.55,8.15 EEG Built and Natural environment Outdoor 0.95