Table 4.
Domain 1 | Domain 2 | Domain 3 | Domain 4 | Domain 5 | Overall Risk of Bias | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Study ID | 1.1 Random allocation? | 1.2 Allocation sequence concealed? | 1.3 ROB | 2.1. Participants blinded to the intervention? | 2.2. Carers/interventionists blinded to the intervention? | 2.3 ROB | 3.Outcome data available for all participants? | 3.2 Bias due to Missing outcome? | 3.3 ROB | 4.1 Inappropriate method to measure the outcome? | 4.3 ROB | 5.1 Pre-specified analysis plan? | 5.2 Selected reported outcome? | 5.3 A priori protocol? | 5.4 ROB | Summary ROB |
S01 | Yes | Yes | Low | NI | PY | SC | Yes | No | Low | No | Low | Yes | No | No | Low | SC |
S02 | No | PY | SC | NI | NI | SC | No | NI | SC | No | Low | No | PN | N | High | High |
S03 | Yes | PY | Low | PN | PY | SC | Yes | PN | Low | No | Low | No | No | PY | SC | SC |
S04 | Yes | PN | Low | NI | NI | Low | Yes | No | Low | No | Low | PY | N | N | SC | SC |
S05 | PY | PN | Low | PN | PY | Low | Yes | PN | Low | No | Low | PY | PN | PY | Low | Low |
S06 | Yes | PY | Low | No | PN | Low | Yes | PN | Low | No | Low | PY | PN | Yes | Low | Low |
S07 | Yes | PY | Low | No | No | Low | PY | Y | SC | No | Low | PN | No | No | SC | SC |
S08 | Yes | Yes | Low | PY | PN | SC | PY | PN | Low | PY | Low | PY | PN | PN | SC | SC |