Table 1.
Authors (year of publication) | Origin of sample | Group comparisons | N | Age range | % Male | Ethnic and racial distribution of sample |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Child-only sample (6–12 years old) | ||||||
Granell de Aldaz, et al. (1987) [47] | Venezuela | 1: SR | 57 | 3–13a | 44 | – |
2: No SR | 57 | 3–13a | 47 | |||
Adolescent-only sample (13–17 years old) | ||||||
Adams (1997)* [50] | USA | 1: SR | 35 | 13–16 | 57 | – |
2: No SR | 35 | 80 | ||||
Carless, et al. (2015) [16] | Australia | 1: SR | 60 | 12b–17 | 53 |
97% Caucasian 3% Asian |
2: No SR | 46 | 12b–17 | 39 | |||
Ficula, et al. (1983)** [54] | USA | 1: SRc | 11 | 14–17 | 45.4 | – |
2: SAP not SR | 11 | 81.8 | ||||
3: No SR or SAP | 19 | 47.3 | ||||
Place, et al. (2002) [63] | USA | 1: SR | 17 | 12b–15 | 65 | – |
2: No SR | 643 | – | – | |||
Child and adolescent samples (6–17 years old) or not specified | ||||||
Bahali, et al. (2011) [48] | Turkey | 1: SR (hospitalised) | 55 | – | – | – |
2: No SR | 56 | – | – | – | ||
Cooper (1984) [72] | UK | 1: SRc | 22 | 11–16 | – | – |
2: T | 45 | |||||
3: No SAPc | 84 | |||||
Egger, et al. (2003) [4] | USA | 1: SRc | 165 | 9–16 | 47.9 |
69.9% Caucasian 22.4% Native American 6% African American 0.5% Hispanic 0.2% Asian 1.1% Other |
2: T | 517 | 9–16 | 65.1 | |||
3: Mixte (SR and T) | 35 | 9–16 | 51.9 | |||
4: No SAPc | 705 | 9–16 | – | |||
Foreman, et al. (1997) [73] | UK | 1: SR (hospitalised) | 20 | 11–15 | 50 | – |
2: No SR | 20 | 11–15 | 45 | |||
Havik, et al. (2015) [5] | Norvegia | 1: SR | 3629 | 11–12 | 49.6 | – |
2: T | 13–15 | |||||
Honjo, et al. (2001) [49] | Japan | 1: SRc | 34 | 7–17 | 68 | – |
2: SR + Depression | 10 | 7–17 | 50 | |||
3: No SR or Depressionc | 243 | 12–15 | 46 | |||
Hughes, et al. (2010) [74] | Australia | 1: SR | 21 | 10–14 | 52 | – |
2: No SR | 21 | 10–14 | 52 | |||
Maric, et al. (2012) [17] | Netherlands | 1: SR | 50 | 11–17 | 58 |
92% Dutch 2% Turkish 6% Other |
2: No SR | 181 | 11–17 | 55 |
88% Dutch 3% Surinamese 2% Turkish 1% Moroccan 5% Other |
||
Naylor, et al. (1994) [75] | USA | 1: SR (hospitalised) | 27 | 12–16 | 37 | – |
2: No SR | 27 | 12–16 | 37 | |||
Tomoda, et al. (1997) [76] | Japan | 1: SR | 22 | 12–18 | 45 | – |
2: No SR | 9 | 10–21 | 39 |
Group comparisons: SR school refusal; T truancy; SAP school attendance problem; – not specified
*Thesis; **Published Conference Proceeding
aIn Venezuela, schooling begins at 4 years
bThe authors specify that all participants are in high school
cWhen more than 3 groups were compared in a study, the identified factors concerned the comparison between the SR group and the group without SR