Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 24:1–19. Online ahead of print. doi: 10.1007/s10578-022-01469-7

Table 1.

Description of study characteristics and quality appraisal

Authors (year of publication) Origin of sample Group comparisons N Age range % Male Ethnic and racial distribution of sample
Child-only sample (6–12 years old)
 Granell de Aldaz, et al. (1987) [47] Venezuela 1: SR 57 3–13a 44
2: No SR 57 3–13a 47
Adolescent-only sample (13–17 years old)
 Adams (1997)* [50] USA 1: SR 35 13–16 57
2: No SR 35 80
 Carless, et al. (2015) [16] Australia 1: SR 60 12b–17 53

97% Caucasian

3% Asian

2: No SR 46 12b–17 39
 Ficula, et al. (1983)** [54] USA 1: SRc 11 14–17 45.4
2: SAP not SR 11 81.8
3: No SR or SAP 19 47.3
 Place, et al. (2002) [63] USA 1: SR 17 12b–15 65
2: No SR 643
Child and adolescent samples (6–17 years old) or not specified
 Bahali, et al. (2011) [48] Turkey 1: SR (hospitalised) 55
2: No SR 56
 Cooper (1984) [72] UK 1: SRc 22 11–16
2: T 45
3: No SAPc 84
 Egger, et al. (2003) [4] USA 1: SRc 165 9–16 47.9

69.9% Caucasian

22.4% Native American

6% African American

0.5% Hispanic

0.2% Asian

1.1% Other

2: T 517 9–16 65.1
3: Mixte (SR and T) 35 9–16 51.9
4: No SAPc 705 9–16
 Foreman, et al. (1997) [73] UK 1: SR (hospitalised) 20 11–15 50
2: No SR 20 11–15 45
 Havik, et al. (2015) [5] Norvegia 1: SR 3629 11–12 49.6
2: T 13–15
 Honjo, et al. (2001) [49] Japan 1: SRc 34 7–17 68
2: SR + Depression 10 7–17 50
3: No SR or Depressionc 243 12–15 46
 Hughes, et al. (2010) [74] Australia 1: SR 21 10–14 52
2: No SR 21 10–14 52
 Maric, et al. (2012) [17] Netherlands 1: SR 50 11–17 58

92% Dutch

2% Turkish

6% Other

2: No SR 181 11–17 55

88% Dutch

3% Surinamese

2% Turkish

1% Moroccan

5% Other

 Naylor, et al. (1994) [75] USA 1: SR (hospitalised) 27 12–16 37
2: No SR 27 12–16 37
 Tomoda, et al. (1997) [76] Japan 1: SR 22 12–18 45
2: No SR 9 10–21 39

Group comparisons: SR school refusal; T truancy; SAP school attendance problem; – not specified

*Thesis; **Published Conference Proceeding

aIn Venezuela, schooling begins at 4 years

bThe authors specify that all participants are in high school

cWhen more than 3 groups were compared in a study, the identified factors concerned the comparison between the SR group and the group without SR