Table 1.
References | Study design | Study population | Race, ethnicity, and SES | Description of intervention | Mode of delivery | Level of support | Outcome measures | Results (effect size if available) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Empirical studies testing virtual care interventions in youth with eating disorders | ||||||||
Aardoom et al. [12, 22] | RCT |
N = 273 Mean age = 24.4 (range not reported, over 16) Sex = 99% females Diagnosis = approximated DSM-5 diagnosis using EDE-Q self-report; 97.6% above clinical significance cut-off Recruited = via Featback website of Dutch recovery e-community The Netherlands |
NR | Featback, a fully automated Internet-based monitoring and feedback intervention was offered alone and with additional high- and low-intensity online therapist support in comparison to a waiting list control | Online: depending on condition, all online including for therapist support | 2 of the 4 conditions include email, chat, and Skype support from therapists | SEED |
Featback was superior to waitlist control for bulimic psychopathology (d = 0.16) as well as for ED-related quality of life at 3 month follow up (d = 0.22) No effect for anorexia nervosa psychopathology Additional support significantly enhanced patient experience of treatment but did not impact effectiveness |
Aardoom et al. [23] | RCT |
N = 273 Mean age = 24.4 (range not reported, over 16) Sex = 99% females Diagnosis = approximated DSM-5 diagnosis using EDE-Q self-report; 97.6% above clinical significance cut-off Recruited = via Featback website of Dutch recovery e-community The Netherlands |
NR | Featback, a fully automated Internet-based monitoring and feedback intervention was offered alone and with additional high- and low-intensity online therapist support in comparison to a waiting list control | Online: depending on condition, all online including for therapist support | 2 of the 4 conditions include email, chat, and Skype support from therapists | SEED |
Featback was superior to usual care for mild/moderate bulimic but not for mild/moderate symptoms of anorexia nervosa Fully automated monitoring and feedback improved mild to moderate bulimic symptoms. Additional therapist support did not increase effectiveness for these patients |
Anastasiadou et al. [24] | Multicentre RCT |
N = 106 Mean age = 18.06 (SD 6.04) Diagnosis = any ED, according to DSM-5 criteria Recruited from public/private mental health services Spain |
NR | Standard CBT + TCApp, a mobile health intervention including monitoring and chat with therapists (12 weeks) compared to standard CBT alone | Hybrid: included both in-person CBT and the online mobile app in between appointments | Online chat support by therapist (therapist responded minimally once per week) | EDE-Q and SEED |
There were significant but negligible reductions in EDE-Q (d = 0.11) and SEED scores (AN severity index: d = -0.09; BN severity index d = 0.09) for participants overall No significant difference between the 2 groups on longitudinal EDE-Q total and subscales and in severity of SEED |
Anderson et al. [25] | Case series |
N = 10 Age 13–18 years (mean = 16.08, SD 1.99) Sex = 8/10 were females Diagnosis = AN or atypical AN, according to DSM-5 criteria Recruited from medical ads USA |
Ethnicity: all Caucasian SES, race: NR |
Videoconference delivered Family-Based Treatment consisting of weekly family meetings with therapist (20 sessions over 6 months) | Online: intervention delivered completely via telehealth platform | No additional support outside of primary treatment | %mBMI, EDE |
Weight increased from baseline to end of treatment (d = 0.53) and to 6 months follow-up Changes in global EDE and subscales were significant at end of treatment (d = 1.06) and follow-up |
Carrard et al. [26] | Uncontrolled trial |
N = 127 Mean age = 24.7 (18–43 range, SD = 5.1) Sex = female Diagnosis = BN purging type or EDNOS bulimic type, according to DSM-IV criteria Recruited from multiple European treatment centers and ads Switzerland, Spain, Sweden, and Germany |
NR | Internet self-help program based on classical CBT principles | Online: all modules and contact with coach via internet. 1 evaluation session done face to face | Weekly email contact with coach | EDI-2, SCL-90R | Severity of eating disorder symptoms and general psychopathology improved significantly. 45% of participants were considered clinically improved and 23% had no symptoms at end of self-treatment program |
Fichter et al. [27] | RCT |
N = 258 Mean age 23.8 (> 16 years old, SD: 6.5) Sex = female Diagnosis = AN or subthreshold AN without the requirement of amenorrhea according to DSM-IV criteria Recruited from 1 of 8 hospitals in Germany specialized for ED treatment Germany |
Ethnicity: NR SES: middle/upper class |
Internet-based relapse prevention for AN after inpatient treatment using CBT strategies (9 months) compared to no intervention | Online: all components were online (chapters, electronic messaging, online chat room, automatic electronic messages) | Electronic message board for peer support + monthly 1 h chat session with therapist + therapist available via email at any time within 24 h | BMI |
Patients in relapse prevention gained significantly more weight (0.62 BMI points) than patients in TAU condition (0.03 BMI points) (small to medium effect sizes for BMI change in each group from T1 to T2) EDI-2 total score showed greater decrease in TAU group over time from T1 to T2 |
Fichter et al. [28] | RCT |
N = 210 Mean age 23.95, > 16 years old Sex = female Diagnosis = AN or subthreshold AN without the requirement of amenorrhea according to DSM-IV criteria Germany |
Ethnicity: NR SES: middle/upper class |
Internet-based relapse prevention for AN after inpatient treatment using CBT strategies (9 months) compared to no intervention | Online: all components were online (chapters, electronic messaging, online chat room, automatic electronic messages) | Electronic message board for peer support + monthly 1 h chat session with therapist + therapist available via email at any time within 24 h | BMI | There was an overall increase in BMI after the intervention, with a greater increase in the “full completers” group compared to the “partial completers” and the control group. There was also a significant interaction of group by time |
Giel et al. [29] | Uncontrolled trial |
N = 16 Mean age 21.7 (SD 4.3) No details on gender Diagnosis = full or atypical AN according to ICD-10 Recruited from clinic after inpatient care when transitioning to outpatient care Germany |
NR | Relapse prevention program based on Maudsley Model of Anorexia Nervosa Treatment delivered by videoconference (10 sessions over 4 months) | Hybrid: 2 sessions face to face, 8 other sessions via videoconferencing | No additional support outside of primary treatment | Feasibility/acceptability; BMI, EDE-Q | Large effect size for BMI increase after treatment (r = 0.50), small to medium effect sizes for reduction of ED symptoms and scores (r range = 0.06 to 0.57) |
Kim et al. [30] | Uncontrolled trial |
N = 22 Sex = not specified Mean age = 25.27 (SD 8.53) Diagnosis = AN confirmed using SCID-5 according to DSM-5 criteria Recruited = from outpatient clinic of Seoul Paik Hospital South Korea |
NR | TAU in-person (either MANTRA, specialist supportive clinical management, or FBT) augmented by videos about ED recovery tips + daily text messages + 1 weekly face-to-face guidance meeting | Hybrid: vodcast + text-message support + face-to-face therapy | Daily text message from researcher + weekly face-to-face guidance with researcher | Feasibility/acceptability; EDE-Q | Significant reduction in global EDE-Q score (Δη2 = 0.59) and all subscales. No significant change in BMI |
Lock et al. [31] | Multicenter RCT |
N = 40 Sex = 34 female (85%) Mean age = 14.88 (range 12–18 years, SD 1.81) Diagnosis = DSM-5 criteria for AN Recruited = through clinics, hospitals, and online advertisements Canada, USA |
Ethnicity:85% white, 5% Asian, 20% other SES: majority high income |
Comparison of online guided self-help family-based treatment for parents of children with AN and family-based treatment delivered via videoconferencing | Online: self-help modules were completely internet-based. Family-based treatment was delivered fully via videoconferencing | Manualized guidance provided by a “coach” therapist (avg 3.90 h over 4–6 months). For videoconferencing group: no additional support outside of online therapy sessions | %EBW, EDE |
In the videoconference arm, participants gained an average of 8.63 percentage points of EBW (Cohen's d = 1.46) and in the guided self-help arm, participants gained an average of 9.97 percentage points (Cohen's d = 1.51) The EDE Global score decreased on average from 2.94 to 1.55 (Cohen's d = 1.04), with roughly equivalent reductions noted across both treatment arms (videoconference: 2.89 to 1.56; Cohen's d = 1.03; guided self-help: 2.99 to 1.54; Cohen's d = 1.01) |
Marco et al. [32] | RCT |
N = 34 Mean age = 21.82 (range of 15–40, SD 5.75) Sex = females Diagnosis = BN, EDNOS, or AN, according to DSM-IV-TR Recruited from outpatient program for EDs Spain |
NR | CBT for EDs (15 sessions) augmented by CBT for body image in EDs using virtual reality (8 psychotherapy sessions with VR techniques) | Hybrid: all components were technically in person, although the VR is a technology that could be done online now | No additional support outside of primary treatment | Body image (BAT, BIATQ, BASS, SIBID, BITE, EAT) |
All participants significantly improved body image (η2 = 0.35, corresponding to a large effect size). Effect maintained during 1-year follow-up Those with VR showed more improvement than those without VR |
Neumayr et al. [33] | Pilot RCT |
N = 40 Sex = female Mean intervention group = 20.75 (range 15–36 years, SD 6.4), mean control group = 18.00 (range 15–30 years, SD 3.73) Diagnosis = primary AN diagnosis, according to ICD-10 criteria Recruited from inpatient treatment centers for EDs Germany |
NR | Therapist-guided smartphone-based aftercare (Recovery Record) + TAU vs. TAU alone | Hybrid: therapist-guided use of smartphone app w/in-app therapist feedback + face-to-face therapy (TAU) | Once or twice weekly in-app feedback from therapist | EDE-Q |
No significant difference in BMI or EDE-Q (intervention vs. control group) from baseline to postintervention and from baseline to follow-up From baseline to postintervention: nonsignificant between-group differences of moderate effect size on EDE-Q global score (mean difference, intervention group = -0.06; control group = 0.41, d = 0.56) |
Sanchez-Ortiz et al. [34] | RCT |
N = 76 Sex = 75 females, 1 male Mean age = 23.9 (SD 5.9) Diagnosis = DSM-IV criteria for BN or EDNOS Recruited = from higher education institutions through university email addresses, posters, and pamphlets United Kingdom |
Ethnicity: 60% British, 40% other SES: NR |
Internet-based CBT with email support vs. waiting-list control | Online: internet CBT + email support | Email support from therapists ever 1–2 weeks | EDE |
Differences between the internet CBT and the waitlist/delayed treatment groups increased significantly from baseline to 3 months on two of the three primary outcome variables (i.e., the EDE Global score and binge eating) EDE Global score improved in internet CBT group (d = 1.28) from baseline to end of treatment and to a lesser extent in the waitlist/delayed treatment group (d = 0.52) |
Shingleton et al. [35] | Replicated single-case alternating treatment design |
N = 12 Sex 10 females (83%) Mean age = 21.5 (SD 2.35) Diagnosis = DSM-5 diagnostic criteria for AN, subclinical AN, or BN with high dietary restraint/restriction Recruited via community and clinician referrals USA |
NR | Face-to-face therapy (motivational interview + CBT) augmented by motivational text-messages + smartphone self-monitoring. Each participant underwent a semi-randomized sequence of text message and no text message phases. The phases were 1 week in duration and summed to 4 weeks of receiving text messages and 4 weeks of not receiving text messages | Hybrid: in-person therapy + text messages + smartphone app | Participants received individualized motivational text message at each mealtime | RMQ; EDE-Q |
No significant main effects of the text messages on self-reported kilocalorie intake or dietary restraint (operationalized as percentage of EDE-Q questions answered “yes”) when covarying for baseline BMI Significant main effect of the text messages to increase precontemplation scores (Wald chi-square = 17.64) and to increase dietary restraint action scores (Wald chi-square = 14.85) |
Wagner et al. [36] | RCT |
N = 126 Sex = female Mean age for adolescents = 19.31 (range 16–21, SD 1.77) and for adults mean = 26 (range 22–34, SD 3.34) Diagnosis = DSM-IV criteria for BN purging type, EDNOS with binge-eating or purging behavior Recruited via ads Austria |
NR | Internet-based guided self-help program based on CBT strategies (4–7 months) compared to bibliotherapy | Online: programme via internet platform + weekly email support | Weekly emails from therapists guiding program use | EDI-2 | No difference in outcome between conditions. Both groups had significant improvement over time with intervention for monthly binge eating, vomiting, and fasting in both groups |
Wagner et al. [36] | RCT |
N = 126 Sex = females Mean age = 24.55 Diagnosis = DSM-IV criteria for BN purging type, EDNOS with binge-eating or purging behavior Recruited via ads Austria |
NR | Internet-based (email) guided self-help vs. guided bibliotherapy | Online: internet-based self-help + weekly email support | Weekly emails from therapist guiding program use | EDI-2 |
No differences in abstinence and remission rates between the two groups For all EDI-2 scale scores, the scores decreased over time but there were no differences between the two interventions and no interaction |
Wagner et al. [37] | RCT |
N = 126 Sex = females Mean age = 24.55 Diagnosis = DSM-IV criteria for BN purging type, EDNOS with binge-eating or purging behavior Recruited = via ads Austria |
NR | Internet-based (email) guided self-help vs. guided bibliotherapy | Online: internet-based self-help + weekly email support | Weekly emails from therapist guiding program use | BDI; GenPsy SIAB-EX; TCI-R; EDI-2; BNSOCQ |
At the end of treatment, higher motivation to change, higher harm-avoidance, lower baseline frequency of binge eating and lower body dissatisfaction EDI-2 scores predicted good outcomes At follow-up, less baseline frequency of binge eating and higher EDI-drive-for-thinness scores were associated with good outcome at follow-up Higher BDI total scores and lower self-directedness scores at baseline predicted drop-out from therapy |
Wilksch et al. [38] | Pragmatic RCT |
N = 316 (220 met criteria for ED at baseline); Sex = female Mean age = 20.80 (range = 18–25 years, SD 2.26) Diagnosis = AN, BN, BED, or OSFED assessed using EDE-Q Recruited via self-referral by advertisements Australia and New Zealand |
NR | Media Smart-Targeted (MS-T), an internet self-help program vs. receiving tips for positive body image | Online: internet-based self-help program without support | No support provided via app | EDE-Q |
MS-T participants were 75% less likely than controls to meet ED criteria at 12-month follow-up This was statistically significant amongst both nontreatment seekers and treatment seekers who were 71% and 86% less likely than controls to meet diagnosis at 12-month follow-up, respectively |
Observational and mixed-methods studies | ||||||||
Barney et al. [18] | Observational |
Set at Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine clinic Age range = 12–26 years Sex = mostly females 1715 unique patients during this time Diagnosis = any adolescent/young adult health concern, including all EDs Info also included providers, clinical support staff, clerical support staff and other health professionals USA |
NR | Within 1 week of pandemic, all providers used Zoom for telemedicine. By week 2, daily telemedicine sessions began for urgent care, mental health, ED, and addiction treatments | Online: telemedicine clinics, daily 2 h in-person sessions for special cases only | All providers (e.g., nurses, fellows, physicians) continued their assessments and sessions online |
Measured healthcare service usage and qualitative user/provider experience throughout pandemic |
Telemedicine visits increased from 0 to 97% in one month, number of visits comparable to year prior. Providers identified several barriers and solutions to providing different types of care: using earphones for privacy, full training on Zoom, patients submitting results to their patient portal, training families to collect weight at home, having weight taken by nurses, etc. These were identified to help with barriers such as patients not having appropriate devices, technology literacy gap with families, lack of connection etc |
Carretier et al. [39] | Case study and description of implementation of telemedicine during COVID-19 pandemic |
N = 1 (case study) 16-year-old female teenager with restrictive AN Recruited from the Maison des Adolescents where being treated pre-COVID-19 France |
NR | Virtual day hospital care, including individual group, and family therapy was provided by videoconference by a multidisciplinary adolescent medicine clinic | Online: all sessions moved online. for critical cases, some in-person appts possible | No additional support outside of multidisciplinary videoconference therapy | Qualitative case description and discussion | The center was able to move online quickly and efficiently. Benefits of telemedicine are discussed: teleconsultations allow to identify potential risk factors (ex. see how Anna deteriorated during the confinement), telemedicine reduces isolation of patients and allows for clinical support at home, the technology involved is mastered by adolescents and they feel comfortable using it, telemedicine can facilitate the discussion of difficult questions and help work on relationships (ex. helped Anna's family create a dialogue on ED) |
Criquillion et al. [40] | Proposal for a non-randomized clinical trial |
Goal is N = 50 patients Sex not specified Age range = between 12 and 35 years old Recruited from a clinic for EDs, patients (42 patients currently involved in the testing of the app) France |
n/a | A psychoeducational smartphone application including real-time follow-up for use in clinical settings is proposed | Hybrid: partially virtual; followed at the medical clinic regularly, the app on the side for continuity | No support via app, although the patients are followed for the rest of their treatment by doctors at the clinic | Evolution of baseline characteristics | n/a |
Datta et al. [15] | Observational |
Description of patients seen at the clinic: N = 1582 82% female, 17% male, 1% non-binary Mean age = 16.5 (age range up to 25 years, SD 1.72) Diagnosis = mostly AN but included all EDs, as diagnosed by physicians in the specialized ED clinic Recruited from a comprehensive care unit for EDs USA |
NR | Several parts of treatment were delivered via videoconference: 1) psychotherapy and medication management 2) therapeutic groups based on CBT, cognitive remediation therapy (CRT), process group (PG) and parent/patient tele-groups 3) new admission evaluations | Online: mostly videoconferencing for therapy session and group work. When necessary, some in-person | All online aspects of treatments were provided by clinicians: psychologists, psychiatrist, and dietitians. No support outside of regular treatment | Qualitative descriptions of the changes made at the treatment center | All aspects of new admissions, psychotherapy, medication management, and therapeutic groups were moved online where they used videoconferencing. benefits/takeaways are these: 1) useful for parents to take part in initial evaluations remotely 2) remote work generates exposures for social anxiety triggers and complaints 3) videoconferencing useful for bed restriction patients 4) setting group rules is possible and helps when conducting remote group sessions |
Davis et al. [16] | Observational |
No sample population Description of Singapore hospital multidisciplinary ED service for patients 9 to 16 (mean 13.9, SD 1.5) Singapore |
NR | For inpatient: individual meal supervision by nurses. For outpatient: telehealth instituted for physicians and psychologists to manage selected cases and for ongoing engagement with families by psychologists | Hybrid: mix of in person and telehealth | No additional support described outside of videoconference therapy | n/a | The paper describes several considerations for use of telemedicine: for patient/family: willing to use telemedicine, weight stable or good consistent progress, parent willing to weigh patient, no safety concerns, no concerns of medical stability. for health care provider: develop patient eligibility criteria for telemedicine, undergo training in telemedicine |
Kasson et al. [41] | Mixed method |
(a) N = 14 Sex = 100% female Age range = 14- 17 years Diagnosis = clinical or subclinical ED according to DSM-5 criteria, based on self-report questionnaire (excluding clinical AN) Recruited via Instagram & Facebook (b) N = 30 Sex = 13% gender minority, 74% female, 13% male Age range = 14 – 17 years Diagnosis = same as above Recruited via Instagram, Facebook, Snapchat, YouTube, & TikTok USA |
(a) 92% White; 8% Other Hispanic 14%; Non-Hispanic 86% 71% sexual minority (b) 74% White; 26% Other 13% Hispanic; 87% Non-Hispanic 57% sexual minority; 63% LGBTQ + group |
Mobile phone and desktop application, Space from Body and Eating Concerns Program, based on CBT for EDs | n/a | n/a | Stanford-Washington Eating Disorder Screen |
Using social media for recruitment of teens with EDs is feasible and may help in capturing more diverse samples The youth who participated in the survey were highly interested in a mobile app to help with ED recovery |
Rajankar et al. [42] | Intervention description | India | n/a | Proposal for a new smartphone application combining awareness of etiology/informational section, health tracker, calorie tracker, virtual intervention (CBT, DBT, Self-help, support groups), and alert function notifying nearby NGOs/helplines | Smartphone app | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Shaw [43] | Observational |
N = 3 Sex = female Age range = 12–17 years old Diagnosis = AN, as diagnosed by treating physicians in a specialized ED clinic Recruited from an eating disorder treatment service United Kingdom |
NR | 7-week video-conference art therapy sessions held on Microsoft Teams platform | Online: videoconference | No additional support outside of videoconference therapy | Qualitative description of experience | Challenges when working with this client group online include increased body image concerns changed experience of gaze |
Stewart et al. [44] | Mixed methods |
N = 53 Age range = < 18 years old Diagnosis = AN, AAN, BN, ARFID, or other specified feeding and eating disorder, as diagnosed by treating physicians in the specialized ED clinic Recruitment = all clinicians, young people, and parents working or receiving treatment at an outpatient community ED program for youth during data collection were eligible United Kingdom |
NR | Experience in response to COVID-19 pandemic changes: all but essential face-to-face contact was ceased, all outpatient treatment was delivered by video/phone calls | Online only (besides essential services) | No additional support outside primary treatment from family therapists, psychiatrists, nurse therapists, clinical psychologists | Questions about clinician, young people, and parent experience of providing/receiving online treatment | Young people (YP) and parents had overall positive experience with online therapy, low level of impact of technology on treatment experience; Qualitative Themes: Gratitude/something lost/something gained; home as a therapeutic space; changes in therapeutic relationship; implications for the future; trade-off between increasing and limiting access by moving online |
Raykos et al. [45] | Uncontrolled trial |
N = 25 Sex = 93% female Mean age = 24.4 (SD 7.6) Diagnosis = any ED, according to DSM-5 criteria, using EDE & SCID-5 Recruited from patients being followed in an outpatient ED clinic Australia |
70% Anglo/European-Australian | Rapid transition from face to face to telehealth care in an outpatient clinic for EDs, in the context of COVID-19. FBT or CBT was delivered via telehealth, based on age and diagnosis | Online: telehealth | No additional support provided outside regular treatment | EDE-Q, ED-15, CIA, BMI, |
Throughout the study period, patients experienced a large decrease in ED symptoms, comparable to historic benchmarks at the clinic (from pre- to during COVID-19, EDE-Q d = 1.62) Patients rated the quality of treatment and therapeutic alliance highly |
Tregarthen et al. [46] | Observational |
N = 108,996 Sex = 57,940 provided gender (87.2% female) Mean age = 22 (reported by 48,830, range = 13–77 years) Diagnosis = symptom severity assessed by EDE-Q, 87.2% were ≥ 1 SDs above community norms Recruitment = app was made available for download in app stores |
NR | CBT-based self-monitoring smartphone application | Online: smartphone app | No support provided via app | Acceptability; EDE-Q, BMI at baseline |
Acceptability: 2,503 anonymous ratings: 84% were 5/5, 13.3% were 4/5, 1.7% were 3/5, and 1% were 2/5 BMI (calculated for 13,784 users): 10.6% met the BMI suggested weight criterion (< 17.5) for a diagnosis of anorexia nervosa Any occurrence of objective binge episodes 78.8%, subjective binge episodes 76.79%. self-induced vomiting 41.9%, fasting 63.3%, excessive exercise 59.7%, laxative misuse 20.6% |
Yaffa et al. [47] | Case series |
N = 4 Sex = female Age range = 13–17 years Diagnosis = any ED Recruitment = patients were receiving services at a specialized pediatric ED treatment center in a children’s hospital Israel |
NR | Management of pts in the context of COVID-19 pandemic and lockdown | Online: treatment via videoconferencing; in-person visits occurred only in specific conditions | No additional support outside videoconference treatment provided by psychiatrist, clinical nutritionists, psychotherapists | - | The condition of the four adolescents with AN was compromised at the start of the COVID-19 quarantine. The use of multi-disciplinary long- distance telemedicine treatment resulted in an improvement in the condition in three of the four adolescents, living in well-organized families, with the motivation and ability to adjust to the new conditions, but not in one adolescent whose family experienced more problems |
Qualitative studies | ||||||||
Anastasiadou et al. [48] | Qualitative study |
1) N = 8, health care providers and mobile health experts, mean age 34 (SD 7.21), psychiatry, psychology and nursing, males and females 2) N = 9 participants of RCT Mean age = 15 (SD 0.50) Sex = all females Diagnosis = any ED, according to DSM-5 criteria Recruited from RCT participants [24] Spain |
NR | Standard CBT + TCApp, a mobile health intervention including monitoring and chat with therapists (12 weeks) | Hybrid: included both in-person CBT and the online mobile app in between appointments | Online chat support by therapist | Questionnaire assessing services based on effectiveness, user experiences, economic aspects, organizational aspects, sociocultural aspects | Key themes identified by specialists: lack of time, lack of strategic plan, lack of budget, insufficient training, lack of tech support, lack of familiarity and mobile health skills, lack of agreement, insufficient interaction, security/privacy issues. Perceived advantages by patients: ease of use, useful, liked the app design, content appropriate. Perceived disadvantages: problems with design, lack of satisfaction with personalization, some say limited interaction |
Brothwood et al. [49] | Qualitative study |
14 patients and 19 parents Age range = 12 -18 years Mostly females, one male Diagnosis = AN-R, according to DSM-5 criteria Recruited via day program at Maudsley center for child and adolescent ED in London United Kingdom |
NR | During the COVID-19 pandemic, day treatment program based on principles of family therapy was delivered online. Online activities included therapy, groups, meal support, and education support. All kinds of therapy, exercises, worksheets, and coaching for meal support, were provided online | Online: treatment online. Urgent appts offered in person if increased physical or psychiatric risks | Mix of clinician support for groups, therapy, and meals. Some exercises were self-help online | User experience questionnaires | Overall experience was positive (slightly more so for parents), quality partly impacted, parents felt more comfortable, young people reported issues with technology. But majority thought could not have done anything differently. Each component rated by majority as somewhat or very helpful. Compared to face to face, varied response but found less helpful (specifically meal support, family sessions and individual sessions). Young people rated that they want those to be in-person in future but would keep medication reviews or dietetic appts virtually. Qualitative data themes: 1) new discoveries 2) lost in translation 3) best of bad situation |
Lindgreen et al. [50] | Qualitative study |
N = 41 Mean age = 24.0 (age range = 15–41 years, SD 5.9) Sex: 3 male, 38 female Diagnoses = anorexia nervosa and bulimia, as diagnosed by clinicians at the specialized ED treatment facility Recruited = from a specialized ED treatment facility Denmark |
NR | Treatment as usual (for AN: family-based treatment or weekly group/individual sessions; for BN: 10 weekly manualized group sessions followed by an additional group or individual treatment) augmented using Recovery Record (RR) self-monitoring app for eating disorders | Hybrid: in-person sessions augmented by guided self-monitoring smartphone app use | Therapists provided guidance on app usage during in-person therapy sessions | User experience with Recovery Record app | Patient experience with the app depended on its app features, the impact of these features on patients, and their specific app usage. This patient-app interaction affected and was affected by changeable contexts making patients' experiences dynamic |
Naccache et al. [51] | Qualitative study |
N = 8 Mean age = 15.5 (age range = 12–18, SD 1.07), Sex = all females Diagnosis = AN, according to DSM-5 criteria All enrolled in treatment at Toulouse Teaching Hospital France |
NR | Unguided self-help program app: based on psychoeducation, CBT, and motivational interview strategies. Additional emotional management feature and gamification elements | Online: testing only user experience of the smartphone app | No additional support in relation to the app | UEQ and semi-structured interviews | Patient experience of the app was demonstrated with key themes, including finding coping strategies, information, motivational content helpful. Overall, the app was rated positively, although opinions were mixed regarding novelty, dependability and efficiency. Qualitative data showed that patients and clinicians think the psychoeducation portion is important |
Sanchez-Ortiz et al. [52] | Qualitative study (recruited as part of an RCT) |
Interview: N = 9 Sex = female Mean age = 23.2 (SD 3.5) Diagnoses of BN or EDNOS-BN Questionnaire: N = 31 All participants were drawn from those participating in RCT on internet CBT and were students recruited from university networks [34] United Kingdom |
NR | Internet-based CBT program called "Overcoming bulimia online" comprised of immediate iCBT with email support from therapist (4 to 8 sessions) | Online: intervention provided completely online via platform + email | Therapist support via weekly emails | Semi-structured and questionnaires on iCBT treatment experience | Experiences of treatment were summarised in five categories: confidentiality/privacy, flexibility, ease of use, feeling supported, and content of programme. As for impact of treatment, overall positive impression, categorized into: (1) expectations about outcome, (2) effectiveness – reported change in ED symptoms, (3) effectiveness—other changes, and (4) tools for coping in future. As for all RCT participants impressions: struggled to find motivation to continue treatment, knowledge and confidence grew, most useful aspects = weekly emails, problems with access to treatment/technical difficulties, most common suggestion = more support and some face to face* |
Shaw et al. [53] | Qualitative |
N = 43 participants; 19 parents/carers, 12 members of staff, 12 patients, all < 18 years of age Diagnosis = typical or non-typical AN, BN, or BED recruited from a hospital ED service United Kingdom |
NR | Describes experience of adaptations made in response to COVID-19 pandemic | Hybrid: in-person physical examinations with all other appointments online | No additional support outside of primary treatment | Healthcare service usage (hospitalizations, referrals, admissions); user satisfaction, narrative analysis | More referrals accepted in 2020 than 2019, higher % increase for urgent vs. routine consultations (150% vs 129%, respectively); Qualitative results: Using virtual platforms improved ease of access but altered relational experiences |
Case studies | ||||||||
Hellner et al. [54] | Case series |
N = 2 Female Age = 20 and 15, respectively Diagnosis = AN or atypical AN Recruited by Equip providers through postings USA |
NR | Videoconference delivered multidisciplinary treatment based on FBT, CBT, and DBT. Patient met with each provider weekly or more | Online: all done through telehealth and unlimited messages on the telehealth platform | Team support (family therapist, dietitian, peer mentor and family mentor) via chat | Weight gain, EDE-Q short form | Both patients gained at least one pound per week. Scores for EDE-Q decreased by 7–12 point |
Duncan et al. [ 55] | Case study |
N = 1 Sex = female Age = 14 years Diagnosis = EDNOS Recruited from rural tele-psychological clinic in her community USA |
NR | Videoconference delivered therapy, based on cognitive behavioral strategies | Online: all sessions done over videoconferencing platform. 1 appointment was done in person | No additional support outside of primary treatment | n/a | At the end of the 12 sessions of therapy, Mila increased food intake, fell within normal range on growth chart, and scores on CDI no longer elevated |
Study protocols* | ||||||||
Anderson et al. [56] | Case series |
N = 10 (target) Age range = 13–18 years Sex = no specification Diagnosis = DSM-5 criteria for AN or atypical AN Recruited = by referrals and through community USA |
NR | Videoconference delivered Family-Based Treatment consisting of weekly family meetings with therapist (20 sessions over 6 months) | Online: intervention delivered completely via telehealth platform | No additional support outside of primary treatment | Feasibility/Acceptability of FBT via Telemedicine | Protocol only |
Barakat et al. [57] | Multi-site three-arm RCT |
N = 110 (target) Gender will be reported Age range ≥ 16 years Diagnosis = DSM-5 criteria for BN or OSFED with bulimic behaviors Recruited = from general population via advertisement and referrals from health professional Australia |
Income, and cultural background/ethnicity will be reported | Online CBT-based self-help program completed independently vs. completed with therapist guidance (= weekly telemedicine sessions) vs. waitlist control | Online: either online self-help platform or secure videoconference platform | For self-help group with guidance only: weekly 30 min videoconference session with therapist | Frequency of objective binge episodes (EDE-Q) | Protocol only |
Bulik et al. [58] | RCT |
N = 180 (target) Sex: no specification Age range ≥ 18 years old Diagnosis = criteria for DSM-IV BN Recruited from within local health services and via ads USA |
NR | Group CBT delivered via the internet versus face-to-face | Online: online modules with text-based chat group (without audio/video) | Therapist-led chat groups or in-person therapist support in groups | EDE | Protocol only |
de Zwaan et al. [59] | Multicenter RCT |
N = 178 (target) Age range ≥ 18 years old Diagnosis = DSM-IV criteria for BED or subsyndromal BED Recruited = via ads Germany and Switzerland |
NR | Internet-based guided self-help vs. individual in-person CBT | Hybrid: 2 in-person meetings with therapist + internet-based email-guided self help | Therapist support by email | Difference in number of days with OBEs over the past 28 days (assessed by EDE) | Protocol only |
Hambleton et al. [60] | Uncontrolled trial |
Goal is 41 families Age range = 12–18 years Gender will be reported Diagnosis = criteria for AN according to DSM-5 Recruited from regional or rural health district via referral Australia |
SES will be reported | Family-based treatment delivered via videoconference (18 session over 9 months) via telemedicine | Online: via videoconferencing platform (or via telephone if technical difficulties) | No additional support outside of primary treatment | Remission (increase in %mBMI to ≥ 85%) | Protocol only |
Jenkins et al. [61] | RCT |
N = 51 (target) Sex not specified Age range ≥ 17.5 years Diagnosis = regular binge eating in the context of an ED Recruited = clinical referrals United Kingdom |
NR | Self-help delivered face-to-face versus via e-mail versus delayed treatment control condition | Hybrid: first guidance session provided in-person | Therapist support via email, up to twice weekly | Frequency of objective bulimic episodes assessed by EDE-Q | Protocol only |
Kolar et al. [62] | RCT |
N = 30 (target) Sex = female Age range = 12–19 years Diagnosis = AN Germany |
NR | In-person consultations with smartphone app vs. in-person consultations alone | Hybrid: in-person therapy + smartphone app use | Therapist support in-person | Weight gain | Protocol only |
Kolar et al. [63] | Multi-center RCT |
N = 30 (target) Sex = female Age range = 12–19 years Diagnosis = AN or atypical AN confirmed by EDE structured interview Recruited = from waiting list from 3 child & adolescent psychiatry centers Germany |
NR | Face-to-face supportive psychiatric follow-up augmented by therapist-guided use of a DBT-informed smartphone application, (Jourvie) vs. TAU (supportive therapy by psychiatrist) | Hybrid: face-to-face therapy + guided smartphone app use | In-person therapy sessions will include guidance on use of the smartphone app | BMI-SDS, EDI-2 | Protocol only |
Rohrbach et al. [64] | RCT (two-by-two factorial design with repeated measures) |
N = 352 (target) Sex not specified Age range ≥ 16 years Diagnosis = at least mild self-reported ED symptoms on standardized questionnaire Recruitment = community Dutch e-community ED website Netherlands |
NR | (1) Featback, a fully automated self-guided Internet-based monitoring and feedback intervention augmented by weekly chat/email support from an expert patient was compared to (2) Featback without expert patient support, (3) expert patient support only, and (4) waiting list | Online: unguided internet psychoeducation with or without chat/email support | Weekly expert patient support via chat and email (in 2/4 conditions), no additional support in 2/4 conditions | EDE-Q | Protocol only |
Schlegl et al. [65] | RCT |
N = 186 participants (target) Sex = female Age range = 12–60 years Diagnosis = diagnosis of AN at hospital admission, according to DSM-5 criteria Recruited = at an ED clinic Germany |
NR | Therapist-guided smartphone-based aftercare (Recovery Record) + TAU vs. TAU alone | Hybrid: therapist-guided use of smartphone app w/in-app therapist feedback + face-to-face therapy (TAU) | Psychotherapists provide individual feedback via-in app messages | EDE | Protocol only |
ter Huurne et al. [66] | RCT |
N = 252 (target) Age range ≥ 18 year Sex = female Diagnosis = DSM-IV criteria for BN, BED, or EDNOS Recruited = self-selection via targeted ads The Netherlands |
NR | CBT-based internet self-help compared to waiting list control group | Online: intervention and therapist support via online treatment platform | Therapist support by email twice weekly; Forum for peer support | EDE-Q | Protocol only |
NR not reported, n/a not applicable, ED eating disorder, AN anorexia nervosa, AAN atypical anorexia nervosa, AN-R anorexia nervosa restricting type, ARFID avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder, BN bulimia nervosa, BED binge-eating disorder, EDNOS eating disorder not otherwise specified OSFED other specified feeding or eating disorders, ICD-10 international classification of diseases 10th revision, DSM-IV diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders fourth edition, DSM-5 diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders fifth edition, SES socioeconomic status, CBT cognitive behavioral therapy, DBT dialectical behavior therapy, RCT randomized controlled trial, TAU treatment as usual, SCID-5: SEED Short evaluation of eating disorders, %mBMI Percent median BMI, EDE-Q eating disorder examination-questionnaire, EDE eating disorder examination, EDI-2 eating disorder inventory-2, SCL-90R symptom checklist-90-revised instrument, BMI body mass index, %EBW percent expected mean body weight, BAT body attitude test, BIATQ body image automatic thoughts questionnaire, BASS body areas satisfaction scale, SIBID situational inventory of body image dysphoria, BITE bulimic investigatory test, EAT eating attitudes test, BDI Beck depression inventory, GenPsy of SIAB-EX general psychopathology of the structured interview for anorexic and bulimic disorders, TCI-R temperament and character inventory revised, BNSOCQ bulimia nervosa stages of change questionnaire, UEQ user experience questionnaire, BMI body mass index, USA United States of America
*Note that we included these study protocols on the basis that they had the potential of having a sample mean age that fit our inclusion criteria considering their target population