Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 25;12(11):e064673. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-064673

Table 2.

Included studies

No Author(s) Year Programme and study participants Location and
study duration
Individual randomised controlled trials
1 Grépin et al31 2019 M-Kadi
Poor pregnant women without formal education
(469 participated in the CCT arm at end line out of 1401 total. 481 participated in the CCT arm at baseline out of 1514 total.)
Kenya (Vihiga county)
February 2013 to March 2014
Cluster randomised controlled trials
2 Barber and Gertler27 2010 Oportunidades
Pregnant women
(666 treatment and 174 control)
Mexico
1997–2003
3 Kandpal et al36 2016 Pantawid Pamilya
Households below poverty line and with children below age 15 or a pregnant woman
(462 treatment and 704 control)
Philippines (4 provinces)
October to November 2011
4 Okeke and Abubakar29 2020 Conditional cash transfer programme
Expectant women
(5852 treatment and 5000 control)
Nigeria (5 states)
March 2017 to August 2018
5 Triyana26 2016 Program Keluarga Harapan
Pregnant and lactating women
(8303)
Indonesia (6 provinces)
2007–2009
6 Vanhuyse et al30 2022 Afya Credits Incentive
Pregnant women
(2522 treatment and 2949 control)
Kenya (Siaya county)
2017–2019
Controlled before-after studies (all apply difference-in-differences, among other methods)
7 Kusuma et al37 2016 Program Keluarga Harapan
Pregnant and lactating women
(8476)
Indonesia (6 provinces)
2007–2009
8 de Brauw and Peterman35 2020 Comunidades Solidarias Rurales
Pregnant women
(270)
El Salvador
January to November 2008
9 Díaz and Saldarriaga41 2019 JUNTOS
Pregnant women
(9865)
Peru
2000–2011
10 Edmond et al34 2019 CCT programme
Women aged 16 years and above delivering in a health facility
(treatment: 1199 baseline, 1254 end line; control: 1242 baseline, 1237 end line)
Afghanistan (3 provinces)
November 2016 to December 2017
11 Chakrabarti et al39 2021 Mamata Scheme
Pregnant and lactating women aged 19 and above
(11 036 treatment; 163 539 control 1 and 34 320 control 2)
India (Odisha state)
1998–2016
12 Powell-Jackson et al38 2015 Safe Motherhood Programme
Currently married women
(340 323)
India
2001–2008
13 Aizawa40 2020 Safe Motherhood Programme
Women aged 15–49 years
(45 436 treatment and 28 688 control)
India
2005–2016
14 Joshi and Sivaram32 2014 Safe Motherhood Programme
Currently married women
(425 708 total, over two survey rounds)
India
2002–2008
15 Lim et al42 2010 Safe Motherhood Programme
Women
(not clear, but mentioning 182 869 households for latest survey round used in study)
India
2002–2008
16 Debnath44 2021 Safe Motherhood Programme
Women reporting at least one pregnancy since January 2004
(208 816)
India
2002–2008
Interrupted time series analysis
17 Powell-Jackson et al43 2009 Nepal’s Safe Delivery Incentive Programme
Women delivering in health facility with less than 3 children or obstetric complication
(7613 before programme, 7186 after)
Nepal (Makwanpur district)
2001–2007
18 Okoli et al33 2014 SURE-P/MCH
Pregnant women
(20 133)
Nigeria (9 states)
January 2012 to March 2014

CCT, conditional cash transfer; SURE-P/MCH, Subsidy Reinvestment and Empowerment Programme/Maternal and Child Health.