Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 29;12(1):39–55. doi: 10.1007/s13668-022-00446-9

Table 1.

Study characteristics by study design

Study Country Sample size, age Design Intervention /control group Duration Intervention and cultural relevance
Non-randomized trials with or without a control group
Pande et al. [14] India (urban)

N = 20

Age 35–58y

Case–control Both T2D (n = 10) and healthy group (n = 10) received 1 meal/day Acute Provision of low-GI mixed meals using traditional Indian foods and spices in a medical setting.
Pande et al. [15] India (urban)

N = 15

Age 42–58 y

Quasi-experimental, pre-post

Provided meals and snacks

No control group

4 wk Provision of low-GI mixed meals and snacks using traditional Indian foods and spices to cook at home.
Jain et al. [12] India (urban)

N = 180

Mean age 47 y

Quasi-experimental, pre-post

Education

No control group

3 mon In-person education supported with a booklet describing the principles of diabetes management.
Singh et al. [16] India (urban)

N = 120

Age 35–65 y

Quasi-experimental, pre-post

Education

No-intervention control

3 mon In-person nutrition education from dietitians. Type of PA recommended to participants not reported.
Krishnan et al. [13] India (urban)

N = 134

Mean age 50 y

Quasi-experimental pre-post

Counselling–

I – attended 1 session, no follow-up

II – attended dietary counselling with periodic follow-up

III – attended dietary and exercise counselling with periodic follow-up

No control group

3 and 6 mon In-person counselling to participant and caregiver/family, home visits and telephone counselling for those unable to attend in person. Type of physical activity recommended to participants not reported.
Bairy et al. [11] India (urban)

N = 101

Median age 55 y

Quasi-experimental, pre-post

Provision of meals + education as part of an integrated naturopathy and yoga program

No control group

3 mon Meals were low-GI, plant-based, low in salt, oil, sugar. Also engaged in yoga, mild aerobic activity (walking, swimming, boat-pedalling in river), rest, “therapeutic fasting” (1–3 d) + 2 lectures/d on naturopathy, personal development + 1:1 physician counselling + 1-h cooking classes daily. Based on traditional practices. Patients were admitted to a naturopathy hospital for 15- or 30-d treatment.
Kumari et al. [17]

India

(urban)

N = 202

Mean age 53 y

Quasi-experimental

Holistic lifestyle intervention

Usual care controls

3, 6, and 12 mon Interdisciplinary team provided monthly counselling for 6 mon in local language. Supported with pictures, videos, 1:1, and group sessions. Included diet, physical activity (brisk walking, yoga), tobacco cessation, stress management, self-management adherence.
St. John [18] UK N = 34 Quasi-experimental pre-post

Education

No control group

2 mon In-person education supported with a booklet developed for Pakistani immigrants to teach carbohydrate content of traditional foods.
Randomized controlled trials
Johansen et al. [19] Norway

N = 198

Age 26–63 y

RCT

Education

No-intervention control

7 mon In-person, 2-h group sessions on managing blood glucose with diet and exercise (walking). Used culturally adapted resources, translated written materials, focused on traditional foods.
Raberg Kjollesdal [20] Norway

N = 82

Age 28–62 y

RCT

Education

No-intervention control

7 mon Same as Johansen et al. [19]
Myers et al. [21] India

N = 239

Age 25–69 y

Cluster RCT

Education and self-management support

Usual care controls

6 and 12 mon Dietitians received standardized training prior to implementation. Education provided in person by dietitian based on evidence-based nutrition practice guidelines (EBNPG) (Diabetes in India Nutrition Guidelines), motivational interviewing, goal setting, self-monitoring. Participants received handouts including meal plans, exchange lists.
Pavithran et al. [22] India

N = 40

Age 35–65 y

RCT

Nutrition intervention

Controls maintain usual diet

24 wk Educational in-person interview focused on consuming low-GI whole grain cereals using traditional foods, periodically reinforced by a dietitian.
Pavithran et al. [23] India

N = 80

Age 35–65 y

RCT

Nutrition intervention

Controls maintain usual diet

24 wk Educational interview focused on consuming low-GI traditional foods, periodically reinforced by a dietitian.
Yasmin et al. [24] Bangladesh

N = 320

Age 30–85 y

RCT

Interactive voice calls and telephone-based physician access

Usual care controls

6 mon Regular personalized advice regarding diet, physical activity, medications, clinic visits. Call service provided physician contact 24/7.
Devi [25] India (urban)

N = 340

Age 20–80 y

Pre-post, with randomization of participants

I—Education with self-learning module, paper-based

II – Education with a powerpoint presentation

III – usual care control group

6 mon

I—Diet and nutrition self-learning module available in Hindi and English (participant choice) + in-person 90-min discussion in the participant’s home.

II – The same materials provided via laptop with an educator present, and DVD and handout for viewing independently at the participant’s home.

Islam et al. [26] Bangladesh

N = 200

Mean age 48 y

RCT

Text messages

Usual care controls

6 mon Daily text messages (20 out of 90 related to diet) over 6 mon, guided by behavior change theory and diabetes guidelines (Bangladesh + UK and ADA).
Thadchanamoorthy et al. [27] Sri Lanka

N = 135

Mean age 58 y

RCT

I – usual care controls

II – general diabetes management education

III – nutrition education

3 and 6 mon

II – Standard diet based on Dietary Guidelines and Nutrition Therapy for Specific Diseases, Sri Lanka; 4 sessions.

III—Nutrition education focused on low carbohydrate diet; 4 sessions.

Varadaraj et al. [28] India

N = 98

Age 18 + y

RCT

Education comparing 2 intensities

Usual care control

3 and 6 mon In-person nutrition education provided by a dietitian either once monthly or every 3 mon after an initial session (also provided to the usual care control).

ADA American Diabetes Association, DVD digital video disk, GI glycemic index, PA physical activity, RCT randomized controlled trial, UK United Kingdom