Table 1.
Study | Country | Sample size, age | Design | Intervention /control group | Duration | Intervention and cultural relevance |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Non-randomized trials with or without a control group | ||||||
Pande et al. [14] | India (urban) |
N = 20 Age 35–58y |
Case–control | Both T2D (n = 10) and healthy group (n = 10) received 1 meal/day | Acute | Provision of low-GI mixed meals using traditional Indian foods and spices in a medical setting. |
Pande et al. [15] | India (urban) |
N = 15 Age 42–58 y |
Quasi-experimental, pre-post |
Provided meals and snacks No control group |
4 wk | Provision of low-GI mixed meals and snacks using traditional Indian foods and spices to cook at home. |
Jain et al. [12] | India (urban) |
N = 180 Mean age 47 y |
Quasi-experimental, pre-post |
Education No control group |
3 mon | In-person education supported with a booklet describing the principles of diabetes management. |
Singh et al. [16] | India (urban) |
N = 120 Age 35–65 y |
Quasi-experimental, pre-post |
Education No-intervention control |
3 mon | In-person nutrition education from dietitians. Type of PA recommended to participants not reported. |
Krishnan et al. [13] | India (urban) |
N = 134 Mean age 50 y |
Quasi-experimental pre-post |
Counselling– I – attended 1 session, no follow-up II – attended dietary counselling with periodic follow-up III – attended dietary and exercise counselling with periodic follow-up No control group |
3 and 6 mon | In-person counselling to participant and caregiver/family, home visits and telephone counselling for those unable to attend in person. Type of physical activity recommended to participants not reported. |
Bairy et al. [11] | India (urban) |
N = 101 Median age 55 y |
Quasi-experimental, pre-post |
Provision of meals + education as part of an integrated naturopathy and yoga program No control group |
3 mon | Meals were low-GI, plant-based, low in salt, oil, sugar. Also engaged in yoga, mild aerobic activity (walking, swimming, boat-pedalling in river), rest, “therapeutic fasting” (1–3 d) + 2 lectures/d on naturopathy, personal development + 1:1 physician counselling + 1-h cooking classes daily. Based on traditional practices. Patients were admitted to a naturopathy hospital for 15- or 30-d treatment. |
Kumari et al. [17] |
India (urban) |
N = 202 Mean age 53 y |
Quasi-experimental |
Holistic lifestyle intervention Usual care controls |
3, 6, and 12 mon | Interdisciplinary team provided monthly counselling for 6 mon in local language. Supported with pictures, videos, 1:1, and group sessions. Included diet, physical activity (brisk walking, yoga), tobacco cessation, stress management, self-management adherence. |
St. John [18] | UK | N = 34 | Quasi-experimental pre-post |
Education No control group |
2 mon | In-person education supported with a booklet developed for Pakistani immigrants to teach carbohydrate content of traditional foods. |
Randomized controlled trials | ||||||
Johansen et al. [19] | Norway |
N = 198 Age 26–63 y |
RCT |
Education No-intervention control |
7 mon | In-person, 2-h group sessions on managing blood glucose with diet and exercise (walking). Used culturally adapted resources, translated written materials, focused on traditional foods. |
Raberg Kjollesdal [20] | Norway |
N = 82 Age 28–62 y |
RCT |
Education No-intervention control |
7 mon | Same as Johansen et al. [19] |
Myers et al. [21] | India |
N = 239 Age 25–69 y |
Cluster RCT |
Education and self-management support Usual care controls |
6 and 12 mon | Dietitians received standardized training prior to implementation. Education provided in person by dietitian based on evidence-based nutrition practice guidelines (EBNPG) (Diabetes in India Nutrition Guidelines), motivational interviewing, goal setting, self-monitoring. Participants received handouts including meal plans, exchange lists. |
Pavithran et al. [22] | India |
N = 40 Age 35–65 y |
RCT |
Nutrition intervention Controls maintain usual diet |
24 wk | Educational in-person interview focused on consuming low-GI whole grain cereals using traditional foods, periodically reinforced by a dietitian. |
Pavithran et al. [23] | India |
N = 80 Age 35–65 y |
RCT |
Nutrition intervention Controls maintain usual diet |
24 wk | Educational interview focused on consuming low-GI traditional foods, periodically reinforced by a dietitian. |
Yasmin et al. [24] | Bangladesh |
N = 320 Age 30–85 y |
RCT |
Interactive voice calls and telephone-based physician access Usual care controls |
6 mon | Regular personalized advice regarding diet, physical activity, medications, clinic visits. Call service provided physician contact 24/7. |
Devi [25] | India (urban) |
N = 340 Age 20–80 y |
Pre-post, with randomization of participants |
I—Education with self-learning module, paper-based II – Education with a powerpoint presentation III – usual care control group |
6 mon |
I—Diet and nutrition self-learning module available in Hindi and English (participant choice) + in-person 90-min discussion in the participant’s home. II – The same materials provided via laptop with an educator present, and DVD and handout for viewing independently at the participant’s home. |
Islam et al. [26] | Bangladesh |
N = 200 Mean age 48 y |
RCT |
Text messages Usual care controls |
6 mon | Daily text messages (20 out of 90 related to diet) over 6 mon, guided by behavior change theory and diabetes guidelines (Bangladesh + UK and ADA). |
Thadchanamoorthy et al. [27] | Sri Lanka |
N = 135 Mean age 58 y |
RCT |
I – usual care controls II – general diabetes management education III – nutrition education |
3 and 6 mon |
II – Standard diet based on Dietary Guidelines and Nutrition Therapy for Specific Diseases, Sri Lanka; 4 sessions. III—Nutrition education focused on low carbohydrate diet; 4 sessions. |
Varadaraj et al. [28] | India |
N = 98 Age 18 + y |
RCT |
Education comparing 2 intensities Usual care control |
3 and 6 mon | In-person nutrition education provided by a dietitian either once monthly or every 3 mon after an initial session (also provided to the usual care control). |
ADA American Diabetes Association, DVD digital video disk, GI glycemic index, PA physical activity, RCT randomized controlled trial, UK United Kingdom