Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 12;11:1062. Originally published 2022 Sep 16. [Version 2] doi: 10.12688/f1000research.124904.2

Table 1. Characteristics of the included studies in the meta-analysis.

Author and year Continent Sample size Population ROB Prevalence
Osborn et al. 1990 NA 385 Dentists Low 68.31
Rundcrantz et al. (a) 1990 Eu 311 DA Low 83.28
Rundcrantz et al. (b) 1991 Eu 311 Dentists Low 84.24
Marshall et al. 1997 Au 355 Dentists Low 81.97
Akesson et al. 1999 Eu 74 ALL Low 91.89
Kerosuo et al. 2000 Eu 228 Dentists Low 70.61
Lalumandier et al. 2001 NA 5119 ALL Low 47.14
Anton et al. 2002 NA 95 DA Low 92.63
Szymanska 2002 Eu 268 Dentists Low 91.42
Tezel et al. 2005 Asia 221 DS Low 85.97
Leggat et al. 2006 Au 285 Dentists Low 87.37
Polat et al. 2007 Asia 120 Dentists Low 94.17
Puriene et al. 2008 Eu 1670 Dentists Low 86.53
de Carvalho et al. 2009 SA 227 DS Low 70.93
Akar et al. 2009 Asia 185 DA Low 23.78
Ayers et al. 2009 Au 560 Dentists Low 59.82
Dajpratham et al. 2010 Asia 163 ALL Low 96.93
Kierklo et al. 2011 Eu 220 Dentists Low 90.00
Ellapen et al 2011 Africa 94 Dentists Low 54.26
Moradia and Prakash 2011 Asia 77 ALL Low 63.64
Sankar et al. 2012 Asia 259 Dentists Low 41.70
Tzu et al. 2012 Asia 197 Dentists Low 92.39
Muralidharan et al. 2013 Asia 73 Dentists Low 78.08
Kumar et al. 2013 Asia 536 Dentists Low 100.00
Vuletic et al. 2013 Eu 89 Dentists Low 69.66
Kazancioglu et al. 2013 Asia 608 Dentists Low 87.01
Rafeemanesh et al. 2013 Asia 58 Dentists Low 82.76
Zoidaki et al. 2013 Eu 80 Dentists Low 82.50
Movahhed et al. 2013 Asia 177 DS Low 83.62
Sustova et al. 2013 Eu 182 DS Low 39.01
Vora et al. 2014 Asia 86 Dentists Low 62.79
Zarra and Lambrianidis 2014 Eu 120 Dentists Low 60.83
Mendegeri et al. 2014 Asia 60 Dentists Low 88.33
Shadmehr et al. 2014 Asia 446 Dentists Low 80.94
Kursun et al. 2014 Asia 264 DS Low 48.48
Tirgar et al. 2015 Asia 60 Dentists Low 93.33
Gupta et al. (a) 2015 Asia 877 Dentists Low 71.04
Humann et al. 2015 NA 488 DA Low 98.36
Sakzewski et al. 2015 Au 466 Dentists Low 86.05
Kanaparthy et al. 2015 Asia 134 DS Moderate 53.73
Aljanakh et al. 2015 Asia 68 Dentists Low 77.94
Alghadir et al. 2015 Asia 146 Dentists Low 84.93
Hodacova et al. 2015 Eu 575 Dentists Low 97.91
Bhagwat et al. 2015 Asia 200 Dentists Low 57.50
Gupta et al. (b) 2015 Asia 2879 Dentists Low 100.00
Sahu et al. 2015 Asia 206 Dentists Low 81.07
Tamo et al. 2015 Asia 156 Dentists Low 70.51
Batham and Yasobant 2016 Asia 93 Dentists Low 92.47
Rehman et al. 2016 Asia 120 DS Low 70.00
Kriangkrai et al. 2016 Asia 68 DS Low 100.00
Rayyan et al. 2016 Asia 191 DS Low 83.77
Cho et al. 2016 Asia 401 Dentists Low 86.78
Phedy et al. 2016 Asia 241 Dentists Low 63.49
Freire et al. 2016 SA 94 Dentists Low 90.43
Al-Rawi et al. 2016 Asia 101 Dentists Low 67.33
Barry et al. 2017 NA 337 DA Low 80.42
Garbin et al. 2017 SA 204 Dentists Low 81.37
Taib et al. 2017 Asia 82 Dentists Low 100.00
Al-Hourani et al. 2017 Asia 81 DA Low 100.00
Revankar et al. 2017 Asia 150 Dentists Moderate 81.33
Hegde et al. 2018 Asia 200 Dentists Low 97.00
Hosseini et al. 2019 Asia 136 Dentists Low 91.91
Scepanovic et al. 2019 Eu 87 ALL Low 79.31
El Naji et al. 2019 Asia 134 Dentists Low 19.40
Benlidayi et al. 2019 Asia 99 DS Low 85.86
Zafar et al. 2019 Asia 142 DS Low 58.45
dos Santos et al. 2019 SA 241 DS Low 82.57
Meisha et al. 2019 Asia 234 Dentists Low 70.09
Gandham et al. 2019 Asia 150 Dentists Low 58.67
Khandan et al. 2020 Asia 51 Dentists Low 84.31
Netanely et al. 2020 Asia 102 DA Low 89.22
Harris et al. 2020 NA 647 DA Low 82.53
Pope-Ford et al. 2020 NA 14 Dentists Moderate 92.86
Senosy et al. 2020 Asia 66 Dentists Low 89.39
Shekhawat et al. 2020 Asia 72 Dentists Low 100.00
Rahman et al. 2020 Asia 82 DA Low 81.71
Uppada et al. (b) 2020 Asia 624 Dentists Low 69.07
Aboalshamat 2020 Asia 332 ALL Low 81.33
Ohlendorf et al. (b) 2020 Eu 450 ALL Low 95.78
Ohlendorf et al. (a) 2020 Eu 406 DA Low 98.52
Uppada et al. (a) 2020 Asia 156 Dentists Low 84.62
Kumar M et al. 2020 Asia 151 ALL Low 58.28
Berdouses et al. 2020 Eu 1500 Dentists Low 54.07
Ahmad et al. 2020 Asia 244 Dentists Low 86.48
Hashim et al. 2021 Asia 202 DS Moderate 68.32
Alnaser et al. 2021 Asia 186 Dentists Low 47.85
Gandolfi et al. 2021 Eu 284 ALL Low 84.86
Felemban et al. 2021 Asia 377 DS Low 91.25
Bhuvaneshwari et al. 2021 Asia 545 Dentists Low 88.07

Eu: Europe; NA: North America; SA: South America; Au: Australia; DA: Dental auxillaries; DS: Dental students; ALL: All types of dental health care personnel; ROB: Risk of Bias.