TABLE VII:
Results of a fully-supervised 3D UNet trained with our Shadow-AUG and Shadow-DROP mechanisms where the Shadow-DROP layers are deployed at different stages of the segmentation network. Bold values indicate the best result. Underlined values suggest results without statistical significance compared with the top row (p>0.05).
| Models | UCLA dataset | NIH dataset | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DSC[%] | ASD[mm] | HD[mm] | DSC[%] | ASD[mm] | HD[mm] | |
| Shadow-DROP at encoder | 92.25(2.19) | 0.93 (0.29) | 5.89(1.93) | 89.85 (3.30) | 1.26 (0.58) | 6.88 (3.00) |
| Standard dropout at encoder | 91.62(2.48) | 1.03(0.39) | 6.42(2.27) | 81.57(7.40) | 2.62(1.31) | 13.78(5.92) |
| Shadow-DROP at bottle-neck | 92.17(2.32) | 0.94(0.32) | 5.93 (1.97) | 89.61(3.56) | 1.30(0.63) | 7.20(3.37) |
| Standard dropout at bottle-neck | 92.32 (2.43) | 0.93(0.35) | 6.17(2.44) | 89.32(6.01) | 1.32(0.72) | 7.78(3.83) |
| Shadow-DROP at decoder | 92.01(2.41) | 0.97(0.34) | 6.14(2.22) | 89.36(4.23) | 1.34(0.70) | 7.72(3.85) |
| Standard dropout at decoder | 92.29 (2.40) | 0.93 (0.33) | 5.76 (2.08) | 89.21(6.00) | 1.41(1.60) | 7.63(5.02) |
| Shadow-DROP at all layers | 92.12(2.32) | 0.95(0.31) | 5.99(2.04) | 89.86 (3.40) | 1.29 (0.63) | 7.88(4.35) |
| Standard dropout at all layers | 91.48(2.44) | 1.05(0.38) | 6.48(2.33) | 82.75(6.73) | 2.27(1.22) | 11.82(4.94) |