Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 17;13:1038824. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1038824

Table 2.

Meta-analysis results related to relationship between leadership in HEIs and academic staff’s job satisfaction.

Variables K N r 95% CI (Confidence Interval) Q Q b
Lower Limit Upper Limit
Leadership and job satisfaction 57 7,283 0.374 0.247 0.502 2866.371*
Moderator [Leadership style] 51.786*
Transformation 19 0.569* 0.392 0.746
Transactional 13 0.265* 0.052 0.478
Passive 9 −0.412* −0.669 −0.156
Servant 5 0.658* 0.313 1.003
Spiritual 2 0.894* 0.354 1.435
Other 9 0.632* 0.375 0.890
Moderator [The continent] 6.219
America 22 0.273* 0.063 0.484
Asia 20 0.316* 0.096 0.536
Africa 6 0.373 −0.028 0.773
Europe 9 0.754* 0.424 1.084
Moderator [The national culture] 710
Collectivist 26 0.348* 0.157 0.538
Individualistic 31 0.397* 0.221 0.573
Moderator [Human development index] 0.682
Low 5 0.332 −0.110 0.774
Medium 4 0.319 −0.175 0.812
High 6 0.612* 0.207 1.016
Very high 42 0.350* 0.197 0.504
*

p < 0.01.