Skip to main content
. 2022 Nov 18;10:1046243. doi: 10.3389/fped.2022.1046243

Table 2.

This table presents a list of the included studies, summarizing the number of patients, classification of fracture, associated lesions, age at surgery, surgical technique performed, length of follow-up, results and conclusions.

Authors Year of pubblication Title Study type Number of cases (surgically treated) Classification of fracture Associated fractures Average age at surgery Surgical treatment Length of follow-up Final results
Caterini et al. 2002 Fractures of the olecranon in children. Long-term follow-up of 39 cases. Retrospective 5 Caterini: 5 types NO 7.4 years ORIF
cerclage wiring (4 cases)
one screw (1 case)
32 years Good: 4 cases
poor: 1 case
 (inadequate reduction)
Karlsson et al. 2002 Fractures of the olecranon during growth: a 15–25-year follow-up. Retrospective 11 Horne and Tanzer: 3 types NO 11 years ORIF
figure-of-eight wiring (6 cases)
tension band wiring (2 cases)
Rush pin (1 case)
CRIF
percutaneous pinning (2 cases)
19 years Excellent: 9 cases
good: 2 cases
(occasional symptoms)
Gicquel et al. 2003 Surgical technique and preliminary results of a new fixation concept for olecranon fractures in children. Retrospective 6 Bracq: 3 types 2
(radial head)
10.2 years CRIF
two threaded pins
(percutaneous)
14 months Excellent: 5 cases
good: 1 case
(limited ROM—10° flexion +
associated radial head fracture)
Gortzak et al. 2006 Pediatric olecranon fractures: open reduction and internal fixation with removable Kirschner wires and absorbable sutures. Retrospective 6 Intra-articular displaced fractures
(no specific classification)
3 (humeral condyle—1, radial head—2) 9.7 years ORIF
removable K wires and figure-of-eight suture
13 months Excellent: 5 cases
good: 1 case
(limited ROM—10° extension)
Corradin et al. 2016 Outcome of isolated olecranon fractures in skeletally immature patients: comparison of open reduction and tension band wiring fixation versus closed reduction and percutaneous pinning. Retrospective 22 AO PCCF classification: 3 types NO 10.5 years ORIF
tension band wiring (10 cases)
CRIF
percutaneous 4.5mm cannulated screw (12 cases)
17.9 momths Quick DASH score: 1.82/3.42
no statistical significant difference
between the 2 groups
 (limited ROM—20° extension—4 patients)
Kim et al. 2017 Early range of motion exercise in pediatric patients with olecranon fractures treated with tension band suture with double loops and double knots. Retrospective 12 AO PCCF classification: 3 types 2 (radial head) 10.6 years ORIF K wires and figure-of-eight suture early ROM 12 months Perfect MEPS: 12 cases
Perkins 2018 Olecranon fractures in children and adolescents: outcomes based on fracture fixation. Retrospective 46 Intra-articular displaced fractures (no specific classification) 5 (radial head—4 distal radius—1) 12.3 years ORIF tension band wiring (17 cases) tension band suture (29 cases) 9.1 months Revision fixation (TBW: 1 case TBS: 4 cases) children eavier than 50 kg having higher rates of fixation failure with TBS
Li et al. 2022 Short-Term Outcomes of Herbert Screw Fixation for Isolated Olecranon Fractures in Children: A Single-Institution Retrospective Study. Retrospective 14 Mayo: 3 types NO 11.3 years CRIF two 3 mm Herbert screw (percutaneous) 11.9 months Quick DASH score: 1.58