Table 1.
Study | Deficit (%) | Muscle actions | Assessment details | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fmax | RFD | Function | ||||||
Older non-fallers vs. fallers | Bento et al. 2010# | Non-fallers Fallers |
n=13 n=18 |
-17.6 | -17.2 | Dorsi+Plantar flex, Hip ext+flex+abd+add, Knee ext+flex |
RFD20-80% | |
Crozara et al. 2013 | Non-fallers Fallers |
n=22 n=21 |
-11.1 | -10.3 | Dorsi+Plantar flex, Knee ext+flex | RFD50ms | ||
Kamo et al. 2019 | Non-fallers Fallers |
n=34 n=88 |
-2.4 | -13.8 | Knee ext | RFD200ms | ||
LaRoche et al. 2010 | Non-fallers Fallers | n=12 n=11 |
-18.5 | -12.8 | Dorsi+Plantar flex, Knee ext+flex |
RFD200ms | ||
Morcelli et al. 2016a,b | Non-fallers Fallers |
n=24 n=20 |
-10.7 | -24.1 | Hip ext+flex+abd+add | RFD50ms, RFD100ms, RFD150ms, RFD200ms | ||
Palmer et al. 2015# | Non-fallers Fallers |
n=9 n=6 |
-35.3 | -37.3 | Hip ext | RFD50ms, RFD100-200ms | ||
Pijnappels et al. 2008 | Non-fallers Fallers |
n=10 n=7 |
-26.1 | -39.3 | Knee ext, Leg press, Plantar flex | RFD100ms | ||
Weighted mean 95% CI [lower: upper] | Participants Studies | n=295 N=7 | -10.8 [-12.2 : -9.4] | -17.8 [-25.5 : -10.0] | ||||
Older lower vs. higher functioning | Clark et al. 2013# | Fast walkers Slow walkers |
n=12 n=8 |
-40.7 | -14.7 | Plantar flex | RFDmax
Long walkmax, Short walkusual+max, SPPB |
|
LaRoche et al. 2011 | Normal strength Low strength |
n=11 n= 13 |
-23.7 | -28.0 | -11.0 | Dorsi+Plantar flex Knee ext+flex |
RFD200ms
Chair rise, Short walkusual, SPPB |
|
Palmer et al. 2016# | Higher function Lower function |
n=9 n=6 |
-19.2 | -36.1 | Knee ext+flex | RFD50ms, RFD200ms | ||
Weighted mean 95% CI [lower: upper] | Participants Studies | n=59 N=3 | -22.0 [-31.9 : -12.0] | -34.4 [-40.8 : -27.9] | -12.7 [-13.7 : -11.7] | |||
Older vs. younger adults | Crozara et al. 2013 | Young Old |
n=18 n= 43 |
-39.0 | -59.3 | Dorsi+Plantar flex Knee ext+flex |
RFD50ms | |
Inacio et al. 2019# | Young Old |
n=15 n=15 | -34.4 | -49.8 | Hip abd+add | RFDpeak | ||
Izquierdo et al. 1999 | Young Old |
n=12 n=10 | -46.6 | -64.9 | Squat | RFDpeak | ||
Mackey et al. 2006 | Young Old |
n=25 n=25 | -4.3 | -15.6 | Plantar flex | RFD0-85% | ||
Morcelli et al. 2016a,b | Young Old |
n=18 n=44 | -46.5 | -62.6 | Hip ext+flex+abd+add | RFD50ms, RFD100ms, RFD150ms, RFD200ms | ||
Palmer et al. 2017# | Young Old |
n=11 n=11 | -17.6 | -24.3 | Hip ext | RFD50ms, RFD100ms, RFD150ms, RFD200ms | ||
Sundstrup et al. 2010 | Young Old | n=49 n=18 | -21.7 | -21.8 | Knee ext | RFD100ms, RFD200ms | ||
Unhjem et al. 2019# | Young Old |
n=9 n=32 | -4.8 | -31.2 | -23.4 | Leg press (dyn) | RFD30ms, RFD50ms, RFD100ms, RFD150ms, RFD200ms
Chair rise, Short walkusual, Stair climb |
|
Weighted mean 95% CI [lower: upper] |
Participants Studies | n=355 N=8 | -27.0 [-41.6 : -12.3] | -40.8 [-59.0 : -22.5] | -23.4 | |||
PD patients vs. healthy controls | Malling et al. 2016 | Healthy controls PD patients |
n=17 n=13 | -25.4 | -33.0 | STS (up+down) | RFD0-70%
Chair rise |
|
Noorvee et al. 2006# | Healthy controls PD patients | n=12 n=12 | -6.1 | -26.2 | -13.2 | Knee ext | RFD200ms
Short walkusual |
|
Pääsuke et al. 2002# | Healthy controls PD patients | n=12 n=14 | -7.3 | -35.5 | -49.3 | Knee ext (unilat.), STS (up) | RFDmax
Chair rise |
|
Pääsuke et al. 2004# | Healthy controls PD patients | n=16 n=12 | -19.5 | -32.6 | -31.7 | Knee ext (bilat.), STS (up) | RFDmax
Chair rise |
|
Weighted mean 95% CI [lower : upper] | Participants Studies | n=108 N=4 | -11.3 [-19.1 : -3.5] | -30.4 [-36.1 : -24.7] | -30.7 [-47.3 : -14.1] | |||
All | Weighted mean 95% CI [lower: upper] | Participants Studies | n=817 N=22 | -20.5 [-29.4 : -11.7] | -30.6 [-40.8 : -20.4] | -25.9 [-36.1 : -15.6] |
STS: sit to stand. SPPB: short physical performance battery. #: Fmax and RFD outcomes that were initially reported as absolute values, but subsequently normalised by body mass reported by the study. In studies reporting data from more than one muscle action, mean deficit values of Fmax and RFD (based on a mean RFD value in studies reporting data on more than one RFD measure), respectively, were calculated and presented. In studies reporting data on more than one measure of physical function, a mean deficit value of Function was calculated and presented.