Table 1.
Author/ Year/Country |
Organisational affiliation | Funding body | Target group | Guideline development group |
Guideline review/journal publication |
Guideline update | Evidence base methods | LoE | SoR |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AAOS 2021 US [36] |
AAOS | AAOS | Orthopaedic surgeons, other healthcare providers, medical practitioners | Multidisciplinary | Internal and external N |
5 years | SLR GRADE |
Y | Y |
VADoD 2020 US [38] |
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and Department of Defence (DoD) | VADoD | Primary care providers or specialists | Multidisciplinary | Internal and external N |
NR | SLR GRADE |
N | Y |
Zhang 2020 China [32] |
Rheumatology and Immunology Specialized Committee, Cross-Straits Medicine Exchange Association | Rheumatology and Immunology Expert Committee of the Cross-Strait medical and Health Exchange Association | Chinese clinicians, specialists, professionals involved in management of OA | Multidisciplinary | Internal and external Y |
2022 | SLR GRADE RIGHT checklist |
Y | Y |
Kolasinski 2019 US [3] |
ACR | ACR and the Arthritis Foundation | Patients and clinicians | Multidisciplinary | External Y |
NR | SLR GRADE |
Y | Y |
Bannuru 2019 US [4] |
OARSI | OARSI | Clinicians | Multidisciplinary | External Y |
NR | SLR GRADE |
Y | Y |
Bruyere 2019 Belgium [34] |
ESCEO | ESCEO | Clinicians | Multidisciplinary | Internal and external Y |
NR | SLR GRADE |
N | Y |
Ariani 2019 Italy [29] |
ISR | ISR | Physicians, health professionals, patients and policy makers | Multidisciplinary | External Y |
Stated (no planned date) | SLR AGREEII |
Y | N |
RACGP 2018 Australia [37] |
RACGP | Funded in part by Medibank Better Health Foundation | General practitioners, health professionals | Multidisciplinary | External (approved by Chief Executive Officer of NHMRC) N |
5 years | SLR GRADE |
Y | Y |
Kloppenburg 2018 The Netherlnds [28] |
EULAR | EULAR | All health professionals, patients and relevant stakeholders (e.g. policy makers, health insurance companies) | Multidisciplinary | Internal Y |
NR | SLR AGREEII |
Y | Y |
AAOS 2017 US [35] |
AAOS | AAOS | Clinicians, surgeons, specialists, allied health | Multidisciplinary | Internal and External N |
5 years | SLR GRADE |
Y | Y |
Tuncer 2017 Turkey [30] |
TLAR | NR | Clinicians | Multidisciplinary | Internal Y |
NR | SLR Oxman-Guyatt index and Jadad Scale |
Y | Y |
Rillo 2016 Venezuela [31] |
PANLAR | PANLAR | NR | Multidisciplinary | Internal and External Y |
NR | SLR Jadad scale |
Y | Y |
NICE 2014 UK [39] |
NICE | NICE | Clinicians, patients | Multidisciplinary | External N |
Stated (No planned date) | SLR GRADE |
Y | N |
Fernandes 2013 Norway [27] |
EULAR | EULAR | Clinicians, healthcare providers, researchers in OA, policy makers | Multidisciplinary | Internal Y |
NR | SLR EULAR Standard operating procedure |
Y | Ya |
MOH 2013 Malaysia [33] |
MSR | Ministry of Health Malaysia (MOH) and MSR | Healthcare professionals, relevant stakeholders in all healthcare setting | Multidisciplinary | External N |
2017 | SLR Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network |
Y | Y |
Abbreviation.
AAOS: American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons.
ACR: American College of Rheumatology.
AGREE II: Appraisal of Guidelines Research and Evaluation II.
ESCEO: European Society for Clinical and Economic Aspects of Osteoporosis, Osteoarthritis and Musculoskeletal Diseases.
EULAR: European League Against Rheumatism.
GRADE: Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation.
ISR: Italian Society for Rheumatology.
LoE: Level of evidence.
N: No.
NHMRC: National Health and Medical Research Council.
NICE: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence.
NR: not reported.
MSR: Malaysian Society of Rheumatology.
OA: osteoarthritis.
OARSI: Osteoarthritis Research Society International.
PANLAR: Pan American League of Associations for Rheumatology.
RACGP: Royal Australasian College of General Practitioners.
RIGHT: Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Healthcare.
SLR: systematic literature review.
SoR: strength of recommendation.
TLAR: Turkish League Against Rheumatism.
VADoD: Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defence.
Y: Yes.
Presented as Level of agreement.