TABLE 1.
Review of studies on movement-related beta ERD and ERS in stroke and ALS.
| Authors | Rec. | Task | Subjects | Main Findings |
| A. Stroke | ||||
| Chalard et al., 2020 | EEG | Elbow extension | 15 subjects with different cortical or subcortical stroke sites. Testing: 8–116 months post stroke. | Reduced ERD correlated with increased activation of elbow flexors. |
| Shiner et al., 2015 | MEG | Finger tapping | 10 subjects with single stroke and upper limb motor deficit. Testing: 3–45 months post stroke. | Decreased ERD and ERS amplitude correlated with performance. |
| Rossiter et al., 2014a | MEG | Hand grip task | 23 subjects with different stroke locations. Testing: 0.9–207.9 months post stroke. | Reduced ERD amplitude in lesioned M1 and lower ERD ratio in patients than controls. Greater impairment associated with reduced ERD amplitude in lesioned M1. |
| Espenhahn et al., 2020 | EEG | Tracking and wrist movements | 16 subjects with cortical or subcortical stroke. Testing: 41–220 months post stroke. | ERD amplitude 10% smaller in patients compared to controls. |
| B. Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) | ||||
| Bizovièar et al., 2014 | EEG | Sniffing test; right index flexion | 21 subjects with ALS (2 bulbar onset, 19 spinal onset) | Reduced beta ERD amplitudes in ALS during both tests. Decreased beta ERS amplitude in ALS, ipsilaterally to the movement. |
| Bai et al., 2010 | EEG | Finger extension; motor imagery task | 3 subjects with ALS, 3 subjects with PLS, no normal control group | Presence of ERD and ERS in ALS and PLS. Decreased ERD and ERS in motor imagery task compared to finger movements. |
| Riva et al., 2012 | EEG | Self-paced right thumb extensions | 16 subjects with ALS (mean disease duration: 30 months) | No significant difference in ERD between groups. Reduced ERS in patients. ERS negatively correlated with corticospinal damage. |
| McMackin et al., 2021 | EEG | Go/NoGo task with finger mouse click | 24 ALS patients (median age: 69; range: 59–72 years); 33 age-matched normal controls | Reduced ERD during all trials in patients. Correlation between ECAS cognitive scores and ERS amplitudes. |
| Kasahara et al., 2012 | EEG | Hand grasping motor imagery | 8 subjects with ALS with various motor impairments | Reduced ERD in patients compared to controls. Worsening bulbar scales correlated with reduced ERD. ERS not reported. |
| Hosni et al., 2019 | EEG | Motor Imagery task | 6 subjects with ALS (mean age: 57.0 ± 15.7 years) | Reduced and delayed ERD in patients, particularly during right-hand MI. ERS not clearly detectable. |
(A) Most studies found reduced ERD amplitude in post-stroke patients. (B) In general, ALS studies reported reduced ERD and ERS amplitude.