. 2022 Dec 7;12(54):34850–34873. doi: 10.1039/d2ra06734j

Comparison between SCAPS 1D and wxAMPS software simulation.

Device structure	Software	V _OC (V)	J _SC (mA cm⁻²)	FF (%)	PCE (%)
ITO/PCBM/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.08	22.39	82.56	19.99
ITO/PCBM/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.18	20.86	84.21	20.70
ITO/TiO₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.08	23.8	83.61	21.55
ITO/TiO₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.18	23.00	84.69	23.06
ITO/ZnO/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.085	23.76	83.78	21.59
ITO/ZnO/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.18	21.97	84.81	22.04
ITO/C₆₀/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.07	19.62	82.65	17.47
ITO/C₆₀/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.18	21.09	84.73	21.03
ITO/IGZO/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.09	23.65	79.04	20.42
ITO/IGZO/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.19	22.87	82.02	22.38
ITO/SnO₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.08	23.76	83.54	21.52
ITO/SnO₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.18	21.94	82.62	21.93
ITO/CeO₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	0.92	23.59	66.21	14.44
ITO/CeO₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	—	—	—	—
ITO/WS₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	SCAPS-1D	1.08	23.53	83.91	21.43
ITO/WS₂/Cs₂BiAgI₆/CBTS/Au	wxAMPS	1.18	21.16	84.94	21.23