Table 7.
Representation of the heterogeneity of results and methodology of a selection of recent studies on the usefulness of time to blood culture positivity as a predictor of severity.
Reference | Country | Type of study | Result | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|
Hsieh [131] | Multinational | Meta-analysis | A short TTP was associated with higher mortality and septic shock in some bacterial species, but not in Candida spp. | - Notable biases, presence of heterogeneity, mixing of pediatric and adult populations, important confounding factors not assessed, meta-regression analysis not significant. |
Hamilton [138] | United Kingdom | Prospective multicenter cohort study. | TTP not associated with mortality except in Candida spp. (elevated TTP) and possibly in streptococci. | - More methodological soundness than most studies (includes time to incubation). - Limitations: does not assess time to effective treatment, small samples in some groups. |
Siméon [143], | France | Prospective multicenter cohort study. | A short TTP is related to mortality and to the presence of endocarditis in S. aureus bacteremia. | - Some limitations: small sample, blood culture systems used, does not analyze blood culture volume. |
Kim [139] | Canada | Retrospective study | Elevated TTP is associated with mortality in S. aureus bacteremia. | - Some limitations: retrospective, does not have detailed clinical information, does not analyze foci of infection, does not analyze antibiotic treatment. |
Oldberg [144] | Sweden | Retrospective observational study | No association was observed between TTP with mortality or the presence of endocarditis in E. faecalis bacteremia. | - Some limitations: retrospective study, transesophageal echocardiogram not performed in all patients, does not include patients under treatment, does not analyze blood culture volume. |
TTP: time to positivity