Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 8;11:121. doi: 10.1186/s40249-022-01042-3

Table 3.

Evaluation indicator framework of GOH-IDI based on GT and FAHP-EWM

Selective codes (First-level indicators) Weight (%) Axial codes (Second-level indicators) FAHP weight (%)
Wi
Entropy value
ej
EWM weight (%)
Wj
Integrated weight (%)
Wij
Open codes (Third-level indicators) Weight (%)
1. Human Health 33.33 1.1 Reproductive, Maternal, New-born, and Child Health 20.63 1.47 17.37 19.00 1.1.1 Maternal Health 25.00
1.1.2 Neonatal Health 25.00
1.1.3 Child Health 25.00
1.1.4 Adolescent Fertility 25.00
1.2 Infectious Diseases 19.53 1.54 19.99 19.76 1.2.1 Tuberculosis 20.00
1.2.2 HIV 20.00
1.2.3 Malaria 20.00
1.2.4 Neglected Tropical Diseases 20.00
1.2.5 COVID-19 20.00
1.3 Non-communicable Diseases and Mental Health 15.88 1.49 18.16 17.02 1.3.1 Cardiovascular Disease 20.00
1.3.2 Neoplasms 20.00
1.3.3 Diabetes Mellitus 20.00
1.3.4 Chronic Respiratory Disease 20.00
1.3.5 Suicide 20.00
1.4 Injuries and Violence 13.49 1.27 9.95 11.72 1.4.1 Road Traffic 33.33
1.4.2 Unintentional Poisoning 33.33
1.4.3 Homicide 33.33
1.5 Universal Health Coverage and Health Systems 17.47 1.51 19.01 18.24 1.5.1 Health Coverage 25.00
1.5.2 Research and Development Expenditures on Health Issues 25.00
1.5.3 Domestic Health Expenditures 25.00
1.5.4 Infant Vaccination 25.00
1.6 Health Risk 13.01 1.42 15.52 14.27 1.6.1 Unsafe or Unimproved Water, Sanitation and Hygiene 33.33
1.6.2 Household Air Pollution 33.33
1.6.3 Occupational Risks 33.33
2. Animal Health 33.33 2.1 Animal Epidemic Disease 31.87 2.01 46.69 39.28 2.1.1 Diseases of Domestic Animals 50.00
2.1.2 Diseases of Wild Animals 50.00
2.2 Animal Welfare, Relevant Regulations, and Policy Support 24.66 1.13 5.77 15.22 2.2.1 Overexploited or Collapsed Stocks Fish 50.00
2.2.2 Trawling or Dredging Fish 50.00
2.3 Animal Nutritional Status 17.36 1.13 5.81 11.59 2.3.1 Chicken Meat Production Efficiency 25.00
2.3.2 Pig Meat Production Efficiency 25.00
2.3.3 Cattle Production Efficiency 25.00
2.3.4 Cattle Milk Production Efficiency 25.00
2.4 Animal Biodiversity 26.11 1.90 41.72 33.91 2.4.1 Endemic Mammal Species 16.67
2.4.2 Endemic Bird Species 16.67
2.4.3 Endemic Amphibian Species 16.67
2.4.4 Endemic Reef-forming Coral Species 16.67
2.4.5 Endemic Freshwater Crab Species 16.67
2.4.6 Endemic Shark and Ray Species 16.67
3. Environmental Health 33.33 3.1 Air Quality and Climate Change 23.82 1.66 21.44 22.63 3.1.1 Ambient Particulate Matter Pollution 20.00
3.1.2 Household Solid Fuels 20.00
3.1.3 Ambient Ozone Pollution 20.00
3.1.4 Climate Risk 20.00
3.1.5 Greenhouse Gas 20.00
3.2 Land Resources 19.55 1.58 18.95 19.25 3.2.1 Area at Risk Elevation 20.00
3.2.2 Tree Cover Loss 20.00
3.2.3 Grassland Loss 20.00
3.2.4 Wetland Loss 20.00
3.2.5 Mineral Depletion 20.00
3.3 Sanitation and Water Resources 20.68 1.68 22.24 21.46 3.3.1 Freshwater 33.33
3.3.2 Clean Drinking Water 33.33
3.3.3 Renewable Internal Freshwater Resources 33.33
3.4 Hazardous Chemicals 17.52 1.56 18.12 17.82 3.4.1 Fertilizer Consumption 14.28
3.4.2 Controlled Solid Waste 14.28
3.4.3 SO2 Growth 14.28
3.4.4 NOX Growth 14.28
3.4.5 Wastewater Treatment 14.28
3.4.6 Electronic Waste 14.28
3.4.7 Non-recycled Municipal Solid Waste 14.28
3.5 Environmental Biodiversity 18.42 1.59 19.25 18.83 3.5.1 Protected Areas Representativeness 33.33
3.5.2 Species Habitat 33.33
3.5.3 Biodiversity Habitat 33.33

GOH-IDI global One Health Intrinsic Drivers index; GT Grounded Theory; EWM entropy weight method; FAHP fuzzy analytical hierarchy process