Table 16.
Comparisons for Tension/Compression Spring Design (Descriptive Statistics)
| Algorithm | Best | Mean | Worst | Std Dev |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CSS [28] | 0.012638 | 0.012852 | 0.013626 | 8.3564e−5 |
| RO [68] | 0.012679 | 0.013547 | NA | 0.001159 |
| MCSS [50] | 0.012607 | 0.012712 | 0.012982 | 4.7831e−5 |
| MOPM [74] | 0.012665 | 0.012665 | 0.012665 | 1.87E-08 |
| ISA [75] | 0.012665 | 0.013165 | 0.012799 | 1.59E-02 |
| GWO [76] | 0.012666 | NA | NA | NA |
| TEO [79] | 0.012665 | 0.012685 | 0.012715 | 4.41E-06 |
| SOA [80] | 0.012645 | 0.012666 | 0.012666 | 0.001108 |
| PA [81] | 0.012665 | NA | NA | NA |
| MPA [84] | 0.012665 | 0.012665 | 0.012665 | 5.55E-08 |
| EO [85] | 0.012666 | 0.013017 | 0.013997 | 3.91E-04 |
| SRO [86] | 0.012665 | 0.012665 | 0.012668 | 1.26E-07 |
| CGO [89] | 0.012665 | 0.012670 | 0.012719 | 1.09E-05 |
| TLMPA [91] | 0.012665 | NA | NA | NA |
| SBO [92] | 0.012665 | 0.012687 | 0.012723 | 1.77E-05 |
| HS-WOA + [95] | 0.012666 | 0.012745 | 0.012827 | 0.000105 |
| HS-WOA [95] | 0.012764 | 0.012816 | 0.012918 | 0.000121 |
| AOS [96] | 0.012665 | 0.012738 | 0.013597 | 0.000121 |
| MGA [99] | 0.012665 | 0.012666 | 0.012667 | 5.65E-07 |
| RSO [100] | 0.012656 | 0.012666 | 0.012668 | 0.057894 |
| CPA [101] | 0.012665 | NA | NA | NA |
| SCSO [102] | 0.012717 | NA | NA | NA |
| AHO [103] | 0.0127 | 0.0129 | 0.0151 | 2.17E-04 |
| Proposed Algorithm (PbA) | 0.012665 | 0.013404 | 0.01705 | 0.0013 |