Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 6;23(23):15440. doi: 10.3390/ijms232315440

Table 2.

Comparison of different degrader systems. AbTac: antibody-based PROTAC; ATTEC: autophagy tethering compound; AUTAC: Autophagy Targeting Chimera; AUTOTAC: AUTOphagy TArgeting Chimera; BIAC: bispecific aptamer chimera; CMA: chaperone-mediated autophagy; GlueTac; GlueBody Chimera; LYTAC: LYsosome TArgeting Chimera; Mode-A; molecular degraders of extracellular proteins through the ASGPR; PROTAC: PROteolysis TArgeting Chimera; RIBOTAC: RIBOnuclease TArgeting Chimera; RNA: ribonucleic acid; SNIPER: Specific and non-genetic inhibitors of apoptosis protein (IAP)-dependent protein eraser.

Degradation Pathways Degradation Systems Degradable
Targets
Advantages Limitations Highest Phase
Ubiquitin-proteasome PROTAC Intracellular proteins In vivo, oral, improved selectivity and efficiency, does not require tight binding, catalytic and substoichiometric, definite structure and mechanism High molecular weight, high surface area Phase II
Molecular glue Intracellular proteins Good pharmacology, specific to ligase and substrate Mainly relies on accidential discovery Approved
SNIPER Intracellular proteins Catalytic and substoichiometric, definite structure and mechanism Dependent on E3 ligase IAPs Exploratory
Autophagy AUTAC Cytoplasmic proteins, fragmented organelle Broader targets Lack of detailed mechanism for K63 ubiquitination Exploratory
ATTEC Intracellular proteins, nonproteins Broader targets, low molecular weight, good transmembrane activity, better pharmacokinetics Lack of detailed interaction between LC3 and degraders, high molecular design costs, low versatility Exploratory
AUTOTAC Degradation-resistant aggregates Broader targets Unclarified mechanism Exploratory
CMA-based Transmembrane proteins, aggregates High specificity Low stability and delivery efficiency, dependent on cell penetrating peptides, limited therapeutic effects Exploratory
Lysosomal LYTAC Extracellular proteins, membrane-associated proteins Broader targets Limited clinical applicability, required an antibody or a small synthetic peptide to maintain its characteristics, difficult to determine the optimal linking site, high molecular weight, induced immunogenicity Exploratory
MoDE-A Extracellular proteins Small in size, monodisperse and nonprotein based, well-tolerated immunogenicity Relies on highly expressed ASGPR on hepatocytes Exploratory
BIAC Membrane-associated proteins Costless and easily synthesized In the early stages Exploratory
AbTAC Transmembrane proteins Utilizes two specific binding sites of bispecific antibodies to recruit E3, simple optimization of binding properties, built of human parts, reduced immune response High molecular weight Exploratory
GlueTAC Cell surface proteins Cell-type independent degradation strategy, high specificity and efficiency In the early stages Exploratory
Ribonuclease RIBOTAC RNA Favorable pharmacokinetic profile, low concentration, catalytic High molecular weight, slow cellular uptake Exploratory