Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 12;30(12):34229–34242. doi: 10.1007/s11356-022-24433-3

Table 2.

Individual baseline characteristics for the entire cohort and stratified by greenbelt exposure

Number (%) NDVI, n (%) NDVI_250m, n (%) NDVI_500m, n (%)
Low exposure a High exposure b Low exposure a High exposure b Low exposure a High exposure b p Value
TB case
Total 29,519 (100) 14,778 (49.9) 14,741 (50.1) 14,769 (50.0) 14,750 (50.0) 14,763 (50.0) 14,756 (50.0)
Stratified by sex 0.062
Male 20,937 (70.9) 10,190 (68.9) 10,747 (72.9) 10,167 (68.8) 10,770 (73.0) 10,184 (69.0) 10,753 (72.9)
Female 8582 (29.1) 4588 (31.1) 3994 (27.1) 4602 (31.2) 3980 (27.0) 4579 (31.0) 4003 (27.1)
Stratified by age 0.150
0–64 years 21,311 (72.2) 11,609 (78.6) 9702 (65.8) 11,628 (78.7) 9683 (65.6) 11,636 (78.8) 9675 (65.6)
 ≥ 65 years 8280 (27.8) 3169 (21.4) 5037 (34.2) 3141 (21.3) 5067 (34.4) 3127 (21.2) 5081 (34.4)
Stratified by working environment 0.000
Indoor 17,872 (60.5) 6265 (42.3) 11,607 (78.7) 6215 (42.1) 11,657 (79.0) 6171 (41.8) 11,701 (79.3)
Outdoor 11,647 (39.5) 8513 (57.7) 3134 (21.3) 8554 (57.9) 3093 (21.0) 8592 (58.2) 3055 (20.7)
Stratified by occupation 0.000
Intelligent-intensive 5214 (17.7) 3663 (24.7) 1551 (10.5) 3669 (24.8) 1545 (10.5) 3679 (24.9) 1535 (10.4)
Labor-intensive 24,305 (82.3) 11,115 (75.3) 13,910 (89.5) 11,100 (75.2) 13,205 (89.5) 11,084 (75.1) 13,221 (89.6)
Stratified by region 0.000
Urban 9211 (31.2) 8039 (54.3) 1172 (8.0) 8095 (54.8) 1116 (7.6) 8234 (55.8) 977 (6.6)
Rural 20,308 (68.8) 6739 (45.7) 13,569 (92.0) 6674 (45.2) 13,634 (92.4) 6529 (44.2) 13,779 (93.4)
Stratified by city 0.479
Hefei 18,087 (61.3) 10,186 (68.9) 7901 (53.6) 10,296 (69.7) 7791 (52.8) 10,337 (70.0) 7750 (52.5)
Huainan 8288 (28.1) 3880 (26.2) 4408 (29.9) 3882 (26.3) 4406 (29.9) 3853 (26.1) 4435 (30.1)
Huangshan 3144 (10.7) 712 (4.9) 2432 (16.5) 591 (4.0) 2553 (17.3) 573 (3.9) 2571 (17.4)
Detainee c 0.177
Yes 426 (1.4) 221 (1.4) 205 (1.4) 236 (1.6) 190 (1.3) 233 (1.6) 193 (1.3)
No 29,093 (98.6) 14,557 (98.6) 14,536 (98.6) 14,533 (98.4) 14,560 (98.7) 14,530 (98.4) 14,563 (98.7)
Source of TB 0.000
Health check or contact check 305 (1.0) 193 (1.3) 112 (0.8) 189 (1.3) 116 (0.8) 195 (1.3) 110 (0.7)
Clinical consultation 4260 (14.4) 1816 (12.2) 2444 (16.6) 1836 (12.4) 2424 (16.4) 1826 (12.4) 2434 (16.5)
Transfer treatment 24,954 (84.5) 12,769 (96.5) 12,185 (82.6) 12,744 (86.3) 12,210 (82.8) 12,742 (86.3) 12,212 (82.8)
Diagnostic classification 0.000
I 5 (0.0) 2 (0.0) 3 (0.0) 2 (0.0) 3 (0.0) 2 (0.0) 3 (0.0)
II 146 (0.5) 67 (0.5) 79 (0.5) 65 (0.4) 81 (0.5) 67 (0.5) 79 (0.5)
III 27,253 (92.3) 13,692 (92.6) 13,564 (92.1) 13,684 (92.7) 13,569 (92.0) 13,696 (92.8) 13,557 (91.9)
IV 1795 (6.1) 890 (6.0) 905 (6.1) 885 (6.0) 910 (6.2) 877 (5.9) 918 (6.2)
V 320 (1.1) 127 (0.9) 193 (1.3) 133 (0.9) 187 (1.3) 121 (0.8) 199 (1.3)
Sever case 0.007
Yes 540 (1.8) 375 (1.5) 165 (1.1) 372 (2.5) 168 (1.1) 380 (2.6) 160 (1.1)
No 28,979 (98.2) 14,403 (98.5) 14,576 (98.9) 14,397 (97.5) 14,582 (98.9) 14,383 (97.4) 14,596 (98.9)
Treatment management style c 0.004
The entire supervision 20,450 (69.3) 11,457 (77.5) 9000 (61.1) 11,474 (77.7) 8983 (60.9) 11,531 (78.1) 8926 (60.5)
Intensive supervision 8965 (30.4) 3292 (22.3) 5673 (38.5) 3273 (22.2) 5692 (38.6) 3206 (21.7) 5759 (39.0)
Self-administrative treatment 97 (0.3) 29 (0.2) 68 (0.4) 22 (0.1) 75 (0.5) 26 (0.2) 71 (0.5)

aLow exposure is defined as from the minimum to the median

bHigh exposure is defined as from the median to maximum

cTreatment management style: In order to ensure that patients can adhere to regular medication and complete the prescribed course of treatment, effective management measures must be taken to ensure that patients can complete the course of treatment

NDVI, normalized difference vegetation index; NDVI_250m, normalized difference vegetation index in the 250-m buffer; NDVI_500m, normalized difference vegetation index in the 500-m buffer