Table 1.
Study | Study design | Number | Clinical-pathological features | Follow-up period | Outcome | Prognosis improved | Dosage | Benefited groups | P |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ruel(2015) (12) | Retrospective | 21870 | Intermediate risk patients, as defined by ATA risk and AJCC disease stage T3, N0, M0 or Mx and T1–3, N1, M0 or Mx. | 6y | OS | Yes | Na | Intermediate risk patients, as defined by ATA risk and AJCC disease stage T3, N0, M0 or Mx and T1–3, N1, M0 or Mx. | <0.001 |
Al-Qahtani(2015) (13) | Retrospective | 326 | PTMC with aggressive histopathologic variants, multifocality, extrathyro idal extension, lymphovascular space invasion, tumor size (>0.5 cm) and lymph node involvement |
median 8.05y(1.62-11.4y) | DFS | Yes | 30-200mCi; 100mCi is recommended for N0 |
PTMC with aggressive histopathologic variants, multifocality, lymphovascular space invasion, lymphovascular space invasion, tumor size (>0.5 cm) and lymph node involvement | <0.05 |
Creach(2012) (14) | Retrospective | 407 | Size of PTMC, histological subtype, positive lymph nodes on first WBS, PTMC (≤0.8 cm), lymph node metastases, pathology, vascular invasion, capsular invasion, soft tissue invasion, or positive surgical margins. |
Median 5.3y(0.2-51 y) | 5-y RFS | Yes | Median 100mCi | PTMC (≤0.8 cm), lymph node metastases. | <0.05 |
Kim(2013) (15) | Retrospective | 480 | Patients with PTMC with microscopic extrathyroidal extension, cervical lymph node metastases or multifocality (Intermediate-risk) | median 5.3y(0.08-15.4y) | DFS | No | Cumulative 30-300mCi | Patients with PTMC with microscopic extrathyroidal extension, cervical lymph node metastases or multifocality (Intermediate-risk) | 0.79 |
Ballal(2016) (16) | Retrospective | 254 | Patients with T1-3 tumor, N1a/1b and with no distant metastasis (M0). | 10.3y | DFS | No | 30-100mCi | Patients with T1-3 tumor, N1a/1b and with no distant metastasis (M0). | 0.005 |
Here, current studies with long-term follow-up and large sample sizes are listed.