Table 2.
ATA guidelines | 2019 ESMO guidelines | NCCN guidelines | 2022 ETA Consensus Statement | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Indications | 2009 ATA guidelines | 2015 ATA guidelines | 2018 NCCN guidelines | 2020 NCCN guidelines | 2021 NCCN guidelines | ||
Clinicopathological features guided | Tumor >1.5 cm | (Updated on 2009 ATA Guidelines) | Intermediate-and high-risk | Clinicopathologic findings (+), Dx-WBS (-): | (Updated on 2018NCCN Guidelines) | (Updated on 2020NCCN Guidelines) | 1. High-riskb * |
With post-operatively residual disease | 1.1 Intermediate-riska | (Updated on 2015 ATA Guidelines) | 1. Tumor >2cm; | 1. RAT selectively recommended: | 2. Intermediate-riskc | ||
1.2 High-riskb * | 1. Intermediate-risk: Tumor-related symptoms | 2. MVI (+) | Tumor 2–4 cm | ||||
2. BRAFV600E | 2. High-risk: TERT(+) and BRAFV600E (+) | 3. cLNM (+) | 2. RAT recommended*: | ||||
4. Microscopic margins (+) | Tumor >4 cm | ||||||
5. ETE (+) | ETE (+) | ||||||
EVId | |||||||
Bulky or LNM >5 | Dx-WBS (-), CT/MRI+ | ||||||
Dosage | 100-200 mCi | 30-150 mCi | 50-100 mCi | 50-200 mCi | 50-100mCi | ||
T3&N1: the effectiveness of RAT >150 mCi is uncertain | Intermediate risk: 30-100 mCi | RAI for known disease (100-200mCi) is embodied in RAT (50-100mCi). | High-risk: ≥100mCi; | ||||
High risk: 100 mCi | Intermediate-risk: the benefit of RAT≥100mCi is unclear |
* routinely recommend.
a Intermediate-risk with any of the following: aggressive histology, minor extrathyroidal extension, vascular invasion, or >5 involved lymph nodes(0.2-3 cm).
b High-risk with any of the following: Gross extrathyroidal extension, incomplete tumor resection, distant metastases or lymph node >3 cm.
c Intermediate-risk with any of the following: advanced age, aggressive histologies, increasing volume of nodal disease, extranodal extension, multiple N1 and/or lymph node metastases outside the central neck.
d Extensive vascular invasion (minimally invasive HCC is characterized as an encapsulated tumor with microscopic capsular invasion and without vascular invasion).
Dx-WBS, 131I diagnostic whole-body scan; MVI, minor vascular invasion; cLNM, central lymph node metastases; ETE, extrathyroidal extension; EVI, extensive vascular invasion; CT, computed tomography; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.