Table 4. Review of studies on obesity and metabolic syndrome in the elderly.
Studies | Quality assessment | Summary of findings | Quality | |||||||||
Ref | N | Study design | Limitations | Inconsistency | Indirectness | Imprecision | Publication bias |
Relative effect estimates |
Absolute effect estimates |
|||
CVR: cardiovascular risk; HR: Hazard ratio; I: Important; NA: not applicable; RCT: random clinical trial; Ref: bibliography reference annex 1; SR: systematic review; UV: Unavailable; U: Undetected ; Quality: quality assessed according to GRADE methodology; VI: Very Important ; w: women. | ||||||||||||
How does obesity influence cardiovascular risk in the elderly? | ||||||||||||
38 | 79 | RCT | U | U | I | U | Low | UV | UV | Moderate | ||
39 | 1 588 | Post hoc Analysis |
U | U | I | U | Low | NA | NA | Low | ||
40 | 792 | Transversal study | U | U | I | I | Low | NA | NA | Moderate | ||
41 | NA | Review | I | VI | VI | VI | High | NA | NA | Very low | ||
42 |
221 270 |
SR | I | U | I | I | Low | NA | NA | Moderate | ||
43 | NA | Review | I | UV | UV | UV | Uv | NA | NA | Low | ||
What is the non-pharmacological management of the elderly patient with obesity and/or metabolic syndrome: exercise and diet? | ||||||||||||
44 | 1 868 | RCT | U | U | I | U | U | Recent metabolic syndrome/consumption of cheese: HR 1.31 (1.10. 1.56) (53.8% w) | UV | High | ||
45 | 74 | RCT | U | I | I | I | Low | Decrease of metabolic syndrome from 100% to 51.9% (6months of treatment) 100% a 16.2% (12 months of treatment) |
100% Low-moderate CVR-moderate (treatment) vs 13.5% very high CVR and 27% high risk (p < 0.001) |
High | ||
46 | 260 | RCT | UV | UV | UV | UV | Uv | NA | NA | Moderate | ||
47 | 1 533 | RCT | U | U | U | I | High | UV | UV | High |