Table 1.
Cases involving intracranial injury caused by radiologically confirmed acupuncture needle migration
| Abumi et al4
(1996) |
Hama et al5
(2004) |
Miyamoto et al6
(2010) |
Fukaya et al7
(2011) |
El-Wahsh et al8
(2018) |
Current case | |
| Age (years)/sex | 60/F | 70/M | 47/M | 44/M | NA/M | 55/F |
| Acupuncture point | Posterior neck | Posterior neck | Posterior neck | Posterior neck | Posterior neck | Posterior neck |
| Further needle migration | No | No | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Access | Atlanto-occipital junction | Atlanto-axial junction | Atlanto-occipital junction | Atlanto-occipital junction | Atlanto-occipital junction | Atlanto-occipital junction |
| Needle location | Intradural | Intradural | Intradural | Intra- and extradural | Intra- and extradural | Intra- and extradural |
| Needle direction | Left posterolateral to right anterolateral | Left posterolateral to right anterolateral | Left posterolateral to right anterolateral | Midline | Midline | Right posterolateral to left anterolateral |
| Injury site | Medulla oblongata | Cervical spinal cord / medulla oblongata | Cerebellar tonsil / medulla oblongata | Medulla oblongata | Medulla oblongata | VA |
| Intracranial hemorrhage | None | None | Small subpial hemorrhage | Small subpial hemorrhage | None | None |
| Ischemic stroke | None | NA | None | None | None | None |
| Symptoms | Motor and sensory disturbances in the right upper extremitya | Left facial paresthesiab | Discomfort in the posterior neck | Pain in the left face / lower extremity and dysesthesia in the left lower extremity | None | None |
| Removal surgery | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Surgery-related complication | No | NA | No | No | No | CSF leakagec |
| Outcome | Recovered | Deteriorated | Recovered | Improved | Without neurological deficits | Without neurological deficits |
CSF: cerebrospinal fluid
F: female
M: male
NA: not applicable or not available
VA: vertebral artery
aThese symptoms developed 18 years after acupuncture treatment.
bThe symptom appeared 1 year after the needle penetrated the cervical spinal cord and medulla oblongata.
cSurgical repair was required for postoperative CSF leakage.