Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 4;91:105987. doi: 10.1016/j.ijsu.2021.105987

Table 2.

Summary evaluation of strengths and weaknesses of the models evaluated in this study.

Model Benefits Drawbacks Rat- ing
Delloitte Model Renjen et al.[5,6,11] Clear roadmap
Address human and institutional factors
Provides a tangible timeframe with clear reference points
Can be become overly complicated
Danger of rigidity and protocolisation
*
UK Military Model JDP 01 (8) Conceptually easy to implement
Engages multiple resources
Well tested in real world scenarios
Adaptive and reactive
Robust ensuring antifragility and sustain- ability
Limited focus on tech- nology and artificial in- telligence **
McKinsey Model Atsmon et al.(9) Hirt et al.(10) Explores the entire timeframe of crisis
Builds on established successful models
Simple and transferable concepts
An exemplar of building upon earlier success by other organisations
Difficult to enact on global level
Does not exploit the benefits of advancing technology
***