TABLE 1.
| Psycholytic therapy | Psychedelic therapy | |
| Dosage | Lower doses [e.g., LSD 30-150 mcg, psilocybin 3-15 mg] | High doses (LSD 250-800 mcg, psilocybin 25-40 mg) |
| Intended effects | Activation of the primary process Dream-like symbolic imaginings, regressions, transference phenomena Spontaneous insights Affective arousal and vividness of conscious experience |
Cosmic-mystical “peak experience” Ecstatic experience Self-transcendence Awe Connection to others and to self |
| Theoretical foundation | Psychoanalytic theory Psychodynamic theories |
Foundations in religions and philosophical concepts Transpersonal psychology |
| Number of sessions | Numerous sessions required (5-25) | 1-2 session(s) |
| Therapeutic procedure | Psychodynamic preparation Analytical discussion of experiential material in individual and group sessions |
Strongly suggestive preparation Use of specific environmental conditions and structuring music Reduction in focus on language, narrative creation and meaning making |
| Ego-functions | Ego functions softened Some ego functions altered while others left intact Ego boundaries softened, permeable but essentially retained Capacity for self-reflection (“reflecting ego remnant”) is maintained |
Narrative identity is removed from awareness Ego-dissolution (loss of defenses) leads to experience of mystical experience, flow, cosmic consciousness, etc. Self-reflective ego is dissolved, though memory maintained |
| Therapeutic processing | Facilitation of familiar psychotherapeutic processes: deeper emotional truth, greater self honesty and acceptance Reality adjustment Stimulation to integrate experiences into everyday life |
Narration and affirmation of peak experience Reality adjustments will follow naturally from peak experience Psychotherapeutic processing not relevant to experience |
| Therapeutic goal | Healing through restructuring of the personality in a maturation process Release of infantile parental bonds Change of attachment style |
Direct experience of awe, sacredness, the numinous, etc. Self-transformation through change in self-experience and perspective “Spiritual awakening” |
| Indications | Historical: Classical indications of psychotherapy: neuroses, psychosomatic cases, personality disorders, sexual deviations Contemporary: Same as above | Historical: Alcoholism, terminal patients, drug addiction Contemporary: Cancer related Existential Distress and Demoralization Syndrome and End of life care for individuals in palliative treatments, depression, alcoholism, cigarette addiction, obsessive-compulsive disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder |