Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 2;13:1066995. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2022.1066995

Table 2.

Metagenomic sequencing vs. other techniques used to study qualitatively and quantitatively antibiotic resistance.

Whole-genome sequencing Meta-proteomics Whole-metagenome sequencing Quantitative PCR
Definition The sequencing of an entire genome of a single organism is obtained from a culture to identify species/ strains, genes, and mutations associated with AMR. Identification and quantification of proteins conferring AMR and Multi-drug resistance (MDR) to localized MGEs from microbial communities. A culture-independent approach is used for the identification of all ARGs/ mutations in all organisms present in complex microbial communities. Method for the detection, quantification, and typing of specific microbial species/ strains or ARGs/ markers.
Technique DNA is extracted from bacterial culture and sequenced to generate FastQ reads. The generation of peptides and high-resolution mass spectra analysis to identify and quantify proteins. DNA is extracted directly from a sample and sequenced to generate reads representing the entire microbial community. An enzymatic reaction in combination with fluorophores (SYBR Green and TaqMan) is used to amplify a specific target of interest and quantify gene expression levels.
Advantages + Reproducible High resolution Standardization of analysis methods Rapid turn-around time High specificity Read lengths of 1 – 50Kb Accurate prediction Large-scale protein identification Rapid turn-around time + High resolution Accurate prediction Fast High-throughput detection and quantification of target DNA sequences avoid cross-contamination Sensitivity Specificity
Limitations - Requires cultured organism Computationally demanding Cost - False positives from large datasets False discovery rates in large datasets Limited reproducibility - Difficult to differentiate between host and pathogen Expensive Computationally demanding - Incapable of distinguishing between live and dead cells
Outcome
  • Microbial typing and tracing Ability to predict AMR from only genomic data Discovery of novel resistance genes or mutations

Host-pathogen interaction Virulence factors Antibiotic resistance mechanisms Identification of functions involved in biological pathways
  • Species-or strain level identification AMR Virulence potential Detect Mobile genetic elements Discovery of viruses

Determine the presence of specific genes and alleles AMR profiling Toxin production Typing of strains and isolates