Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 2;9:1039121. doi: 10.3389/fmolb.2022.1039121

TABLE 2.

Newcastle-Ottawa scores of included studies (Note: A star system was used for allow a semi quantitative assessment of study quality. A study was awarded a maximum of four stars for the selection and three stars for exposure/outcome categories. A maximum of two stars were awarded for comparability).

Lead author, year Selection Comparability Exposure/Outcome Reference
Dercle L, 2016 **** ** *** Dercle et al. (2016)
Bigot F, 2017 **** ** *** Bigot et al. (2017)
Svaton M, 2018 **** ** ** Svaton et al. (2018)
Mezquita L, 2018 **** ** *** Mezquita et al. (2018)
Ichiki Y, 2019 *** * ** Ichiki et al. (2019)
Lee CS, 2020 *** * ** Lee et al. (2020)
Swami U, 2020 **** ** *** Swami et al. (2020)
Jiang M, 2020 *** ** *** Jiang et al. (2020)
Takada K, 2020 **** * *** Takada et al. (2020)
Cantini L, 2020 **** * ** Cantini et al. (2020)
Kitadai R, 2020 **** ** *** Kitadai et al. (2020)
Formica V, 2020 *** * *** Formica et al. (2020)
NG YYK, 2020 **** * *** Ng et al. (2021)
Awada G, 2021 **** ** *** Awada et al. (2021)
Brown JT, 2021 *** ** *** Brown et al. (2021)
Ke L, 2021 **** ** *** Ke et al. (2021)
Sato S, 2021 **** ** ** Sato et al. (2021)
Ruiz-Banobre J, 2021 **** ** *** Ruiz-Bañobre et al. (2021)
Stares M, 2021 **** * *** Stares et al. (2021)
Khaki AR, 2021 **** ** *** Khaki et al. (2021)
Tokuyama N, 2021 *** * *** Tokuyama et al. (2021)
Pu D, 2021 **** ** *** Pu et al. (2021)
Onn A, 2021 **** ** *** Onn et al. (2021)
Morimoto K, 2021 **** * *** Morimoto et al. (2021)
de Kouchkovsky I, 2021 **** ** *** de Kouchkovsky et al. (2021)
Zhang Z, 2022 **** ** *** Zhang et al. (2022)
Scheider MA, 2022 **** ** *** Schneider et al. (2022)
Assie JB, 2022 **** * *** Assié et al. (2022)
Chen L, 2022 **** ** *** Chen et al. (2022)
Kim JH, 2022 *** * *** Kim et al. (2022)
Li Y, 2022 **** ** *** Li et al. (2022)
Yoo SK, 2022 **** ** *** Yoo et al. (2022)
Guo Y, 2022 **** ** *** Guo et al. (2022)
Abuhelwa AY, 2022 **** ** *** Abuhelwa et al. (2022)
Wu Y, 2022 **** ** ** Wu et al. (2022)
Stares M, 2022 **** ** *** Stares et al. (2022)