Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec 19;30(13):35554–35571. doi: 10.1007/s11356-022-24767-y

Table 5.

Results of endogeneity test

Variable First stage-lnUR Second stage-lnVI First stage-lnUR Second stage-lnDE
(1) (2) (3) (4)
lnUR 0.9604**  − 0.8956**
(2.09) (− 2.21)
lnGDP 0.1761***  − 0.0861** 0.1761***  − 0.1564**
(13.60) (− 1.12) (13.60) (− 2.30)
lnME 0.0700*** 0.4081*** 0.0700***  − 0.0550
(3.36) (9.31) (3.36) (− 1.42)
lnED 0.0437*  − 0.0393 0.0437*  − 0.0697
(2.72) (− 1.22) (2.72) (− 2.45)
lnEN 0.0085  − 0.0678*** 0.0085  − 0.0015
(1.18) (− 6.85) (1.18) (− 0.16)
lnOR 0.1444***  − 0.0905* 0.1444*** 0.0653
(1.59) (− 1.10) (1.59) (1.06)
lnWATER 0.0805*** 0.0805***
(3.15) (3.15)
Constant 0.6433***  − 2.7686*** 0.6433*** 0.5266
(2.95) (− 4.90) (2.95) (1.06)
Observations 496 496 496 496
R2 0.8008 0.8580 0.8008 0.2804
Province FE Yes Yes Yes Yes
F-Stat 79.10 33.18 79.10 10.97

*, **, and *** indicate significance levels of 10%, 5%, and 1%, respectively.