Table 3.
Differences in follow-up strategies of SSN in guidelines.
Guideline | pGGN diameter | PSN diameter | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
<6mm | ≥6mm | <20mma/30mmb | ≥20mma/30mmb | <6mm | ≥6mm | <8mm | ≥8mm | |
2022 NCCN NSCLC Guidelines | No follow-up needed | CT at 6-12 month to confirm persistence, then CT every 2 years until 5 years | No follow-up needed | CT at 3-6 month to confirm persistence; If unchanged and solid component < 6 mm, annual CT should be performed for 5 years; If the solid component ≥ 6mm, then PET-CT or surgical resection. |
||||
2017 Fleischner Society Guidelines | No follow-up needed | CT at 6-12 month to confirm persistence, then CT every 2 years until 5 years | No follow-up needed |
For solid component <5mm
CT at 3-6 month to confirm persistence, then annual CT until 5 years For solid component ≥5mm CT at 3-6 month to confirm persistence, PET-CT/biopsy/resection are recommended for the persistence of the nodule. |
||||
2013 ACCP Guidelines | No follow-up needed | Annual CT for at least 3 years; If diameter>10mm, early follow-up at 3 months, followed by nonsurgical biopsy and/or surgical resection for nodules that persist. |
CT at 3, 12, 24 month, and then annual CT for at 1-3 years | CT at 3 month to confirm persistence; For persistent, biopsy/surgical resection; For nodule >15 mm at first CT scan, biopsy/PET-CT/surgical resection. |
||||
2016 Clinical
practice consensus guidelines for Asia |
Discuss the role of continued surveillance with patient | Annual CT for at least 3 years | CT at 3, 6, 12 month, and then annual CT surveillance | CT at 3 month, and consider antimicrobial therapy (nonsurgical or surgical biopsy consider PET scanning for staging before biopsy) |
||||
2022 NCCN LCS Guidelines | Annual screening LDCT until the patient is no longer a candidate for definitive treatment; For stable, annual LDCT; For growth(>1.5mm), review at 6 months |
LDCT in 6 month; For stable, annual LDCT; For growth(>1.5mm), review at 6 months or consider biopsy or surgical excision |
Annual screening LDCT until the patient is no longer a candidate for definitive treatment; |
For solid component <6mm
LDCT at 6 month to confirm unchange, then annual LDCT |
||||
For solid component ≥6 to <8mm
LDCT in 3 month or consider PET-CT; if unchanged, LDCT at 6 moth, then annual CT Low suspicion of lung cancer, LDCT in 3 month; Low suspicion of lung cancer, biopsy or resection |
||||||||
For solid component >8mm
Chest CT+ contrast and/or PET-CT; Low suspicion of lung cancer, LDCT in 3 month; Low suspicion of lung cancer, biopsy or resection |
||||||||
Newly developed nodules
LDCT in 6 month |
Newly developed nodules
If solid component <4mm, LDCT in 3 month; If solid component ≥4mm, Chest CT+ contrast and/or PET-CT; Low suspicion of lung cancer, LDCT in 3 month; High suspicion of lung cancer, biopsy or resection. |
|||||||
2019 Lung-RADSb | Continue annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. | ≥ 30 mm and unchanged or slowly growing: Continue annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. ≥ 30 mm on baseline CT or new: 6 month LDCT; unchanged for ≥ 3 months, then annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. |
Continue annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. | With solid component < 6 mm OR new < 6 mm total diameter: 6 month LDCT; unchanged for ≥ 3 months, then annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. With solid component ≥ 6 mm to < 8 mm OR with a new or growing < 4 mm solid component: 3 month LDCT; PET/CT may be used when there is a ≥ 8 mm solid component; Unchanged for ≥ 3 months, then annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. |
a solid component ≥ 8 mm OR a new or growing ≥ 4 mm solid component: Chest CT with or without contrast, PET/CT and/or tissue sampling depending on the probability of malignancy and comorbidities; unchanged for ≥ 3 months, then annual screening with LDCT in 12 months. For new large nodules that develop on an annual repeat screening CT, a 1 month LDCT may be recommended to address potentially infectious or inflammatory conditions. |
|||
pGGN, pure ground-glass nodule; mGGN, mixed ground-glass nodule; NCCN, National Comprehensive Cancer Network; NSCLC, Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer; LCS, Lung Cancer Screening; ACCP, American College of Chest Physicians; CT, computed tomography; LDCT, low-dose computed tomography; PET-CT, Positron Emission Tomography-Computed Tomography; Lung-RADS, Lung imaging reporting and data system; aindicates that 2022 NCCN LCS Guidelines managed pGGN with a limit of 20mm; bindicates that 2019 Lung-RADS managed pGGN with a limit of 30mm.